Indiana Jones and the Great Circle - Review Thread
from ampersandrew@lemmy.world to games@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 02:04
https://lemmy.world/post/22820676

Game Information

Game Title: Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

Platforms:

Trailers:

Developer: MachineGames

Review Aggregator:

OpenCritic - 87 average - 92% recommended - 62 reviews

Critic Reviews

Game Rant - Anthony Taormina - 8/10

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle offers some of the best puzzling and tomb-raiding in a video game, matching Spielberg’s films in many respects.


PC Gamer - Ted Litchfield - 86 / 100

Like if an immersive sim got caught in a teleporter accident with Uncharted. Some aspects of The Great Circle are weaker than others, but it joins Batman Arkham and Goldeneye in the god tier of licensed games.


Eurogamer - Katharine Castle - 5 / 5

Smart, fun and so very Indiana Jones, The Great Circle is a stealth action tour de force that marks a bold new era for MachineGames.


IGN - Luke Reilly - 9 / 10

An irresistible and immersive global treasure hunt, and far and away the best Indy story this century, Indiana Jones and the Great Circle doesn’t belong in a museum; it belongs on your hard drive where you can play the heck out of it.


TheGamer - Eric Switzer - 3.5 / 5

It’s a fun story with some decent gameplay variety that’s authentically Indy. You won’t miss much by strictly sticking to the main quest, and in fact, your experience will be better for it. It’s a shame the rest of it falls so flat.


GamesRadar+ - Josh West - 5 / 5

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle shows that there’s still plenty left for Lara Croft and Nathan Drake to learn about raiding tombs from the master


GameSpot - Richard Wakeling - 9 / 10

Indiana Jones and The Great Circle takes an unexpectedly stealthy and freeform approach, making for a faithful, rip-roaring adventure in which you truly embody the famous archeologist.


I stole this format from @simple@lemm.ee, so I hope I got it all right. This game looks awesome!

#games

threaded - newest

NOT_RICK@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 02:19 next collapse

I’m glad this game is good! Now for the love of God, let them make another Wolfenstein, Microsoft!

BigBananaDealer@lemm.ee on 06 Dec 05:10 next collapse

wow i did not expect such rave reviews. now im extra excited to try this out. hope my fucking shite internet allows the game to download and doesnt randomly stop every 5 minutes

update: yeah ill have to play this tomorrow night 💪😎🤳

Venicon@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 08:26 collapse

I sat with 2mbps for a couple of years. It was quicker to unplug and take my XB to my parents house an hour away to download anything!

Keep the faith, I get 400mbps now and all I had to do was be a little patient, move to a different county and get into crippling debt.

But those download times 🤤

BigBananaDealer@lemm.ee on 06 Dec 16:33 collapse

wow 400 🤯 most ive ever had was 200 but mine hovers around 90 now when it doesnt randomly stop

Venicon@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 16:35 collapse

Thing is after a certain point I can’t even tell the difference any more. I feel like the downloads are throttled from Microsoft’s side so I never quite get the full whack.

BigBananaDealer@lemm.ee on 08 Dec 07:40 collapse

it does cap at a certain point, but i forget the number

Grass@sh.itjust.works on 06 Dec 05:57 next collapse

So its actually good? Honestly surprised. The devs haven’t been canned either?

9cpluss@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 08:08 next collapse

Same here. I thought it was going to be mediocre at best. Still not interested but happy for the people who like such games.

zecg@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 13:42 collapse

I thought it was going to be mediocre at best.

I fully expect it to be a mediocre shooter with some good environmental puzzles and nice graphics, Starfield had 85+/100 reviews before coming out. We’ll find out once it actually releases, in two years with all of the hypothetical DLC included for 15€. Bethesda can fuck right off with their 50€ offerings.

Spuddlesv2@lemmy.ca on 06 Dec 08:09 next collapse

The devs haven’t been canned YET.

Grass@sh.itjust.works on 06 Dec 08:58 collapse

I’ve had this thought that game devs should plant killswitches in their games so if they get mass lay offs the game just stops working and displays messages presented as being from the parent company that tell the user they are banned, and for the most idiotic reasons.

Realistically though if the game is successful by any metric a hacker or dataminer will find it first or it will be abused in some other way.

ampersandrew@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 12:33 collapse

I’m surprised that folks here were surprised that the people behind those Wolfenstein games would make a good game.

inclementimmigrant@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 15:00 collapse

Because we’ve seen time and time again where good devs go bad. Especially when they get bought out.

ampersandrew@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 15:08 collapse

It was worse before the buyout, when Zenimax had an initiative to make everyone make live service games even when it was clearly a bad idea.

TachyonTele@lemm.ee on 06 Dec 08:12 next collapse

I think it’s interesting to look back at other game reviews. You sort of see how much they matter. lemm.ee/post/6176552

Renacles@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 11:49 next collapse

Let people enjoy their games

zecg@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 13:43 next collapse

More power to them, I’ll stick to my hobby of schadenfreude while AAA burns.

ampersandrew@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 13:55 collapse

Even a good AAA game that doesn’t have always-online shenanigans?

TachyonTele@lemm.ee on 06 Dec 14:26 collapse

Who’s stopping anyone from enjoying their games?

zecg@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 13:43 collapse

That’s the first thing that came to mind when I saw the scores, I’m not reading reviews of Bethesda’s games other than players’ reviews on Steam.

HollowNaught@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 12:29 next collapse

I’m always sceptical of critic reviews, considering

newthrowaway20@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 12:29 next collapse

Meh I’m still skeptical. These reviews seem awfully generous compared to the gameplay footage I saw.

inclementimmigrant@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 15:01 next collapse

Just so PC owners are aware, it’s been confirmed that early access will not contain full ray tracing option.

I am very interested in how well various cards will handle the ready tracing options.

theverge.com/…/indiana-jones-and-the-great-circle…

inclementimmigrant@lemmy.world on 06 Dec 15:19 collapse

ACG review.

TL;DW He enjoyed that game but there were enough technical issues so just be aware of the limitations of the game and your rig.

youtu.be/rN5BrUQ9CrA?si=4i8zyVrwlP6_EALq