What are some games you like that most people hate and/or were panned by critics?
from SweetCitrusBuzz@beehaw.org to gaming@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 10:42
https://beehaw.org/post/18241372

What are some games you like that most people hate, view negatively and/or were panned by critics?

#gaming

threaded - newest

Malix@sopuli.xyz on 30 Jan 2025 11:03 next collapse

Aliens: Colonial Marines

IMO, the game is better than it’s reputation - at least in it’s current state. After the .ini tweak to fix the alien ai-typo makes it a bit better - afaik, I can’t remember if my group played it with the fix or not, we’ve played the campaign at least 3 times now.

The game’s not a masterpiece by any means, though. It is pretty enjoyable action game in COOP and fairly high difficulty. Sure, arguments could be made that any game is, but game still more fun than not. Now, would I play the game on my own, as single player? Eeeeeeeh, dunno… But if my gaming group asks to play some ACM, I’m down.

Some random points about the game summarized:

  • Pulserifle goes BRRT, alien goes splat.
  • Could do with less of the human/android enemies though, or at least the parts with androids felt like they dragged on for considerable time.
  • Quite a bit of collectible guns, they’re mostly sidegrades but they are different enough, imo.
  • runs on a toaster
  • goes for pennies on Steam sales, so gaming group funny hours per unit of currency -ratio is pretty good, imo.
DdCno1@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 12:49 collapse

Did you play it with the mod that fixes the Alien AI?

Malix@sopuli.xyz on 30 Jan 2025 12:52 collapse

I did state that I can’t remember - entirely possible we did, but it has been quite a while since we played it.

DdCno1@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 13:03 collapse

Sorry, must have missed this.

Malix@sopuli.xyz on 30 Jan 2025 13:19 collapse

np, it happens. :)

DebatableRaccoon@lemmy.ca on 30 Jan 2025 11:05 next collapse

I think the top one that comes to mind is Days Gone. I can’t help but feel like we’ve played completely different games when seeing reviews for it from the likes of IGN, for example.

drunkosaurus@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 30 Jan 2025 11:52 next collapse

I love me some Days Gone! I still to this day have it installed and go back from time to time to whack a few hordes.

luxyr42@lemmy.dormedas.com on 30 Jan 2025 16:47 next collapse

Release vs now is the difference. Lots of huge improvements went in weeks and months after release that made a huge difference. You are also likely playing on a modern PC or on PS5 as opposed to the original base PS4.

Maestro@fedia.io on 30 Jan 2025 23:05 collapse

I loved this game! I got it for free on PS plus some years ago

DdCno1@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 13:02 next collapse

Year and average review score across all available platforms in brackets. I played all of these on PC.

  • Trespasser (1998, 57): First person shooter based on Jurassic Park. Noteworthy for huge open areas, detailed dinosaurs with procedural animations and a physics engine that would only be surpassed by Half-Life 2 six years later. It is clunky, difficult to control and buggy, a challenge to get running both on contemporary and current PCs, but the atmosphere, the level design and the sheer awe at what they were able to pull off in the '90s is just unbelievable. I first played it many years after its release and it still blew me away.

  • Elex (2017, 62): Open World RPG from the creators of Gothic and Risen. It’s the definition of ‘Eurojank’, with controls that a bit of time getting used to, high difficulty and dated animations. I really enjoyed my time with it though, because it has a gorgeous, well-designed post-apocalyptic open world, clever quests that frequently allow for multiple approaches, factions that are truly different from one another, rewarding combat and interesting progression with tons of player choice. Just like previous games from this developer, it follows the formula of placing strong gatekeeper enemies at choke points, which serve to guide progression - but there’s nothing stopping a skilled and/or determined player from circumventing or outsmarting them. The inclusion of a jet pack makes this more fun than in any other game I’ve played. This device isn’t easy to use, but very early on, at the first location the first companion takes the player to, there’s a transmission tower with a reward at the top. Figure out how to climb it with the jet pack - which may take a few attempts - and you’ll have learned how to use this jet pack. This is a bit frustrating and can take 20 minutes to half an hour, but once you’ve done this, you’ll notice that the entire game was designed with this mode of transportation in mind. Watching other people play this game is incredibly frustrating to me, because they rarely if ever look up, rarely if ever use it to climb structures and natural obstacles to get to items or gain an advantage in combat. Maybe the developers should have created a more in-depth tutorial on this thing, but I think this is one of the main reasons why people aren’t getting this game.

  • Homefront: The Revolution (2016, 50): Semi-open world first person shooter. Set in a USA that was somehow defeated and is occupied by a hyper-advanced North Korea that is certainly not a clumsy stand-in for China, you’re playing a brave American resistance fighter against the occupation. Spec Ops: The Line, this ain’t - don’t expect any subtlety or finesse to the narration here, but it works as a scenario. The gameplay is where it’s truly interesting. It’s kind of like the opening hours of Far Cry 3, except that you’re not fighting against a few pirates, but a vastly technologically and numerically superior enemy that will hunt you down mercilessly in a half-destroyed American city. The feeling of powerlessness, yet determination, the thrill of pulling off a successful ambush and then scrambling away as the enemy throws everything they have at you is quite something. It’s not without its flaws, mind you. More linear story missions are hit and miss, even after many patches there are still bugs and glitches, it is slightly generic in terms of gameplay, but when everything comes together, it’s a really solid experience.

  • AquaNox 2: Revelation (2003, 59): Underwater first-person shooter masquerading as a submarine game. This is actually the third game in the series, after Archimedean Dynasty (also known under its original German title of Schleichfahrt) and AquaNox 1. The setting is a post-apocalyptic irradiated Earth where the remnants of humanity have fled to the bottom of the oceans to survive. Naturally, the fight for power and resources continue there. I’ve never actually played the predecessors, but this game is one of my favorites from the early 2000s. It looks stunning for the time (no wonder they created a benchmark, AquaMark, using engine and assets from the game) and gameplay is a really interesting 3dof that blends stealth and action in bleak, but varied enough underwater environments. Story and characters are charming, the universe is interesting and it’s just a blast from start to finish. It did receive really high review scores in Europe and especially Germany (lots of 85), so perhaps it’s just a case of international audiences/reviewers not getting it, similar to how Gothic and Risen were far more popular there.

  • Damnation (2009, 38): Probably the worst game on this list. Damnation is a third person shooter set in an alternate-history US Civil War with advanced steampunk technology. The story is extremely poorly presented, controls are clunky, enemy AI is braindead, there

Malix@sopuli.xyz on 30 Jan 2025 13:19 next collapse

Elex

I truly need to give this game another go, can’t really say why I stopped playing it. But it is EuroJank all the way.

Funny tho, I noticed most of the character animations I saw in Elex are straight up the exact same they were in Gothic 3, possibly from even earlier games’ of theirs. Nothing wrong with reusing assets, but damn they’ve gotten some mileage out of them :D

ICastFist@programming.dev on 30 Jan 2025 13:51 collapse

I started Elex but probably stopped around the 3 horu mark, went to play something else. The character you control is a fucking unlikable asshole during those initial hours.

DdCno1@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 20:27 collapse

I didn’t have this impression, but maybe the dry German dialogue doesn’t translate well into English.

spiffmeister@aussie.zone on 31 Jan 2025 00:33 collapse

Damnation

Funnily enough this was originally a mod for UT2k4 which was actually pretty good and has good ratings on moddb: https://www.moddb.com/mods/damnation

orb360@lemmy.ca on 30 Jan 2025 14:03 next collapse

Advent Rising had pretty meh reviews but I liked it. Sad it never got it’s sequels.

SteposVenzny@beehaw.org on 31 Jan 2025 05:49 collapse

Flick targeting ruled, people just didn’t give it a chance because it was unfamiliar.

toxicbubble420@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 14:53 next collapse

Legend of Mana has very confusing quests, but the amount of sheer content made it one of my favorite jrpgs of all time

VinesNFluff@pawb.social on 30 Jan 2025 17:06 next collapse

Fable 3

It got a lot of flak back then, mostly because people were sick to shit of Peter Molyneux promising THE WORLD and delivering, like, JUST A GAME.

But here’s the thing. I didn’t follow gaming news. I didn’t know what a Peter molyneux was. I just know I got a fun little action RPG where I get to be royalty, and that scratched a very specific itch for me.

Kwakigra@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 20:21 next collapse

Dynasty Warriors series. Some criticism is correct, in that they really did release the same game several times in a row with minor adjustments. The gameplay is much more strategic than it was given credit for, though. It’s true your warrior basically feels like a lawnmower demolishing hundreds to thousands of hapless footsoldiers at a time, but the trick is that you are the army’s only lawnmower. Almost everything your allies try will fail catastrophically unless you help them. You really have to time your presence on certain parts of the fight to be where you’re needed. It feels very heroic. Also, the cutscenes are without exception hilarious and drew me to the source material Romance of the Three Kingdoms which has greatly enriched my life.

knokelmaat@beehaw.org on 30 Jan 2025 23:53 next collapse

Silent Hill: The Short Message (53 on metacritic)

This game is almost universally hated, but I really quite enjoyed it and even respected what they were going for with the writing. My 8/10 review from when I played it: howlongtobeat.com/user/knokelmaat/reviews/…/1

I have no experience with other Silent Hill games, which might have made me less critical of this game. By no means a masterpiece, but an interesting experience for me.

CountCorvinus@beehaw.org on 31 Jan 2025 00:34 next collapse

I enjoyed my time with Redfall. The gunplay wasn’t anything special, but the atmosphere was great. I loved the setting and soundtrack. I thought the art style was cool, and I liked the little bits of lore you could pick up.

The final update brought some big QoL changes to the game. I just look at present day Fallout 76, which launched in an even worse state and wonder what could have became of Redfall if Microsoft hadn’t fired everyone.

Kolanaki@yiffit.net on 31 Jan 2025 01:20 next collapse

Brink was cool, if a bit flawed. It could have become better if they had given it more of a chance.

Shattered Horizon was awesome at first, but eventually the game changed entirely and at some point an update just broke the game for hella people (myself included) so we couldn’t even play on a local server with bots and it was never fixed. :/

AceFuzzLord@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 01:33 next collapse

Extremely easy question: Sonic The Hedgehog (AKA Sonic '06). Such a buggy mess, but I absolutely loved playing it on 360 and definitely wanna play it again some day.

BmeBenji@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 04:44 next collapse

I absolutely loved the nihilistic ending to Mass Effect 3.

BmeBenji@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 04:46 next collapse

Lawbreakers was easily the most fun I had in a multiplayer game ever. Ok, maybe that spot is shared with Titanfall 2, but Lawbreakers is a far better competitive shooter.

I’m still holding out hope that the modding community will crack the server-side code and create a good server browser for it.

BmeBenji@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 04:56 next collapse

The Surge is way better than a sci-fi souls-like attempt that so many reviews seem to argue it is. And Shammy’s review of it really does it better justice than most reviews imo. The limb-targeting system makes it really engaging, and the sequel’s directional parry system adds the depth that Dark Souls and Elden Ring are missing. I highly recommend it for anyone tired of replaying Souls games

[deleted] on 31 Jan 2025 05:34 next collapse

.

Malix@sopuli.xyz on 31 Jan 2025 09:22 next collapse

most people and/or critics hate witcher 3? o_O

wick@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 13:28 collapse

Oh fuck, I misread the OP

feathercloaked@beehaw.org on 31 Jan 2025 10:36 collapse

dropping the witcher 3 as an underrated game. r/gaming moment.

wick@lemm.ee on 31 Jan 2025 13:31 collapse

Dyslexia moment. I completely garbled the OP in my mind. Idek.

feathercloaked@beehaw.org on 31 Jan 2025 10:39 next collapse

you know, for as much shit as mass effect 3 gets, in a lot of ways it’s my favorite of the trilogy.

phuntis@sopuli.xyz on 31 Jan 2025 11:52 next collapse

far cry 5 I don’t think many people hate it as such but just view it as repetitive but it was the first one I played and while most people say putting it in rural montana is boring and not exotic like far crys supposed to be I’m english so rural montana is practically an alien planet and the vibes in the game are immaculate just walking through the wilderness between points on the map to do stuff that down time in between is so nice and when you’re going further distances in the car the radio music is so good and while the stories stupid and the ending is god awful every one of the seeds actors were amazing each one of them was so good even if you don’t get that much time with them I’d honestly say far cry 5 is one of my favourite games ever not my favourite that’s fnv and second is mouthwashing but it’s in joint 3rd place with about a dozen other really good games that I can’t honestly say one is better than the other but I truly love all of them for different reasons

Dalek_Thal@aussie.zone on 31 Jan 2025 22:15 collapse

Veilguard was excellent, but it pissed off bigots and now it’s outright unsafe to speak positively about it on the other site.