from thingsiplay@beehaw.org to gaming@beehaw.org on 01 Nov 2024 22:04
https://beehaw.org/post/16845025
Looks like owner of Ryujinx changed and now is developed by someone else? The top contributor for this is gdkchan, the previous owner and main developer. So this is not simply a fork, but changing ownership of the original repository. Is that right? It makes sense, because what happened previously is that gdkchan got a message (or visit) from Nintendo to stop working on the emulator. That’s all. There was no cease and desist to the entire project, or anything like that (unlike with Yuzu).
Edit: Another hint that this is the original repository is, that a message is displayed that I have blocked a certain user who contributed to this repository. This message does not popup on any of the forks.
Edit 2.0: I may have been wrong: docs.github.com/en/…/transferring-a-repository
If the transferred repository has any forks, then those forks will remain associated with the repository after the transfer is complete.
And looking in the list of forks, the oldest one seem to be 1 month old or so.
threaded - newest
It’s a bit of a leap to say the “owner” changed. Ryujinx is MIT licensed, allowing anyone to clone the original code locally, build upon it, and publish it to a public host. Looks to me like that’s what happened here: a fork, but without using github’s built-in “fork” feature, perhaps to avoid being included in a mass take-down. There are others on non-github sites, although I don’t know if they have been getting new commits.
I don’t see any reason to think the original repo was renamed or moved to another user’s account. The top contributor is gdkchan presumably because gdkchan’s commit history was preserved.
For the record, gdkchan’s last commit to the original repo was on 2024-10-01.
Edit: The README confirms what I thought:
I thought the contributors list would be reset when uploading to a new location. At least that’s for forks, so that was my assumption without checking actually. I mean for the forks, gdkchan still have the commit history too, like any other contributor.
I think you are right: docs.github.com/en/…/transferring-a-repository
And looking in the list of forks, the oldest one seem to be 1 month old or so.
Careful those ten does might Suyu
I think the “owner” is up for grabs since the original repo was DMCA’d. All I know is Nintendo will be playing a game a whack a mole for quite a while, it’s very easy to fork a repo.
As far as I’m aware the original repo wasn’t DMCA’d. It was just taken down by the original Owner after Nintendo asked them to. This seems to be why these new “hard forks” haven’t gotten taken down.