I switched from macos to Linux because it can't stop babying users and being unnecessarily restrictive
from TheTwelveYearOld@lemmy.world to linux@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 02:04
https://lemmy.world/post/28631644

I tried running a 2nd instance of Roblox simultaneously on macos 15 with another account but this shows up, if my mac can handle it then why can’t it just let me do it? If I have two copies of an app like Roblox in separate User/Applications folders, macos moves them to the /Applications/ folder.

Sometimes it won’t run apps claiming to be corrupted, so I then have to do sudo xattr -cr /Applications/someapp.app in the terminal and they run perfectly fine. It always nags me if I download apps from anywhere but mac app store. Some of these messages can only be gotten rid of by disabling system integrity protection, but then macos blocks you from running MAS apps due to having “permissive security”.

I don’t daily drive macOS anymore, I switched to Linux on my M1 mac where I can do whatever the hell I want.

#linux

threaded - newest

[deleted] on 24 Apr 02:11 next collapse

.

daggermoon@lemmy.world on 24 Apr 07:55 collapse

OP said it was Mac OS 15.

[deleted] on 24 Apr 13:24 collapse

.

bamboo@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 24 Apr 02:32 next collapse

NGL I think whatever you’re trying to do is either a limitation of the Roblox install or something else that isn’t specifically an OS X issue. The file permission stuff sounds weird and I’d reevaluate what you’re trying to do and if the approach is correct, especially if you’re going to have to turn off operating system security features to get it to work.

jbloggs777@discuss.tchncs.de on 24 Apr 04:12 collapse

github.com/FreeTubeApp/FreeTube/issues/2786#issue… for a real world example of needing an exception.

skribe@aussie.zone on 24 Apr 03:02 next collapse

Can you play Roblox? I thought they blocked it on Linux.

Someplaceunknown@lemm.ee on 24 Apr 03:23 next collapse

Sober lets you play Roblox on Linux

gwilikers@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 06:50 collapse

Why would they do that?

pogmommy@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 07:35 next collapse

All the 8 year old hackers running linux were toppling their child labor industry

cepelinas@sopuli.xyz on 24 Apr 10:08 collapse

I am more suprised that they manages to use linux to cheat.

StarlightDust@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 24 Apr 10:32 collapse

They created a new anticheat for the PC version which broke Linux support

[deleted] on 24 Apr 12:23 next collapse

.

BlackArtist@lemmy.world on 24 Apr 12:23 collapse

Has that broken sober too?

cepelinas@sopuli.xyz on 24 Apr 13:31 next collapse

The newest one broke sober for a while but it works now.

StarlightDust@lemmy.blahaj.zone on 25 Apr 12:25 next collapse

Sober was made in response to it.

BlackArtist@lemmy.world on 25 Apr 12:34 collapse

AHH right that’s great.

skribe@aussie.zone on 24 Apr 08:03 collapse

My understanding is that Roblox requires changes to the kernel to lock it down in order to prevent script kiddies from cheating. Linux makes that very difficult to impossible, so they abandoned/never supported the platform.

lukecooperatus@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 09:05 collapse

Jeez. Sounds like Roblox is horribly designed if the only way they can secure their servers is through client side measures.

Scrath@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 24 Apr 09:25 collapse

Sounds like pretty much every multiplayer game with Anti-Cheat is horribly designed in that case…

Anti-Cheat software seems to be the last hurdle preventing widespread compatibility with Linux. Even when there is a linux version of an anti-cheat (BattleEye has a Linux version I believe) companies don’t use that and still restrict their game to windows. Looking at you ubisoft and rainbow six siege

MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 06:58 collapse

I believe Linux versions of ACs are easier to bypass

tyler@programming.dev on 24 Apr 07:06 next collapse

That isn’t a Mac error message. It’s Roblox giving you that error.

bla_bla_bla@feddit.org on 24 Apr 07:50 next collapse

Mac OS sucks but this is a Roblox problem not a Mac OS problem. Btw they recently blocked linux on Roblox so good luck playing that.

Dariusmiles2123@sh.itjust.works on 24 Apr 09:12 next collapse

I’m curious about your experience with a M1 Mac on Linux. Are you using Asahi Linux then?

Crazyslinkz@lemmy.world on 24 Apr 14:33 collapse

I to want answers, I thought m1 had security limits to install Linux or any other os.

HumanPerson@sh.itjust.works on 25 Apr 02:35 collapse

It’s obfuscated but not officially blocked. Their site is asahilinux.org. It’s not worth getting a macbook for yet imo , but it’s still super impressive, especially the graphics drivers. There are issues with Mac’s built in security stuff but that just means the fingerprint reader and probably some other stuff doesn’t work.

Crazyslinkz@lemmy.world on 25 Apr 02:57 collapse

Interesting, thanks

llothar@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 11:20 next collapse

Windows will not allow me to attach a file to an email because it is opened in Word 🤷

MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 06:55 collapse

Word issue, not windows issue 🤔

that_leaflet@lemmy.world on 24 Apr 13:08 next collapse

I love when I try to open a file and macOS tells me I can’t because can’t tell if it’s safe. There’s literally no way to open it from here.

You have to hit ok, then go so settings, scroll down to security, and hit a button to specify yes I actually want to open this file. It then reprompts you again but now with an open anyway button.

I love my MacBook’s hardware and battery life, but MacOS is such a letdown.

sabzian@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 15:14 next collapse

Try right clicking on the file and selecting Open from the menu

FIST_FILLET@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 15:26 collapse

this works in 95% of cases, try this before you go all the way into settings! most annoying part of mac is this stuff

tyler@programming.dev on 24 Apr 15:36 next collapse

You used to be able to hold alt and right click and choose open.

expr@programming.dev on 25 Apr 03:27 collapse

xattr -d com.apple.quarantine path/to/file will remove that shit.

Though personally, I get as much software as possible on my work MacBook through Nix, and only use .dmg files if absolutely required.

p03locke@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 24 Apr 13:44 next collapse

Old, but still relevant:

<img alt="Windows/Linux KILL comparison" src="https://img-9gag-fun.9cache.com/photo/aYe4jpm_700bwp_v2.webp">

apelsin12@lemm.ee on 24 Apr 15:00 collapse

Nope this is untrue

ptu@lemm.ee on 25 Apr 09:52 collapse

Please do elaborate

LifeLemons@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 10:11 collapse

There are many different signals the OS sends to applications which are kinda like “Can you kill yourself?” or “Please kill yourself” or “I will kill you” to close it. In computer teminology, there is “close”, “terminate” and “kill” types of signals. These are used so that applications can have time to perform closing tasks (like saving) when neceassary and if they misbehave, just “kill” it.

Now both windows and linux have these types of signals. In fact every OS has it.

I beleive this is the reason this meme exists:
When the user tries to shut a app in windows (throught close button or task manager) windows will wait and not give any option to immediately kill the app. Hence some apps don’t close even after using end task. Only if the app freezes for some time will it give the option for force quit, no other way (edit: it exists). In linux, its the same as windows and limux waits for app to close. But the difference is that option to kill is available anytime in linux and basically gives the user full control. Although kill option in linux may be hidden as a way for users not to use it unless necassary as applications may not like it.

Shutdown process of both OS is same, they wait for all apps to shut by semding “please close” signal and if they misbehave, option to “shutdown anyways” will be shown to the user, basically killing all apps.

The meme is not correct and is just a steorotype of different OSes. This steorotype comes from how people normally experinece different OS culture and practices. Both OSes have same process of managing apps. Both OSes will wait for process to close if it freezes and give option to user to force quit.
SIGKILL in the meme is coreect only for the right panel of the meme and the left panel is actually a SIGTERM (or something else which means “please close”, don’t remember)

The only thing the meme should emphasis is how the user is given full control to do in linux (even deleting the kernel) while windows is careful to not let users do something stupid.

Edit: Killing apps in windows can be done on demand through cmd using taskkill command

the_crotch@sh.itjust.works on 25 Apr 12:17 collapse

Only if the app freezes for some time will it give the option for force quit, no other way

taskkill /im filename.exe /f

Or if you have multiple instances of the same executable running, you can kill by PID

LifeLemons@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 13:12 collapse

I meant through a graphical user interface. Was saying in view of an average user.

Although it’s true that I wasn’t aware of this commands existance when writing

Pirata@lemm.ee on 24 Apr 14:04 next collapse

NGL that smiley face from Finder looks so condescending lmao. My wife’s laptop is a Mac and it’s hilarious every time how it shows up so often. Like Clippy from Word lol.

nullpotential@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 24 Apr 14:58 next collapse

You shouldn’t play Roblox.

ArsonButCute@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 24 Apr 16:01 collapse

Honestly, instead of playing shitty clones of games made with child labor through roblox, just play the original games they’re cloning.

Couple of weeks ago I was at a friends place for dinner and the son was playing Roblox. Everyone in the room except him knew he was playing a WoW clone. His dad even told him, “you know I’ll buy you a subscription if you wanna play the real game instead of a shitty clone”

Don’t play Roblox. Its just cheap imitations made with child labor.

MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 06:52 collapse

I guess underaged people can’t earn money because it will be child labour… 🤦

Roblox isn’t only about “shitty clones”. Just let people play whatever they want. Just let passionate underaged devs gain money instead of companies.

blinx615@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 09:13 collapse

At minimum, the Roblox company is taking advantage of children by:

  • Taking a large cut of the revenue and obfuscating that information
  • Devs are paid in Robux and the conversion to real currency involves an unfavorable exchange rate with a high minimum
MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 09:18 collapse

They’re taking advantage of everyone with their shitty “dev exchange rates” thing, but it’s known info at this point.

Sadly yea, that’s bad behavior, but I fail to see how it’s specifically taking advantage of children.

ltxrtquq@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 10:45 collapse

You don’t know how the known behavior that takes advantage of everyone, in a game popular with and marketed towards children, is taking advantage of children?

MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 11:02 collapse

Most devs must be above 13-15yo, before you’re not really supposed to have a bank account

Also, it’s a bit light to say that they’re stricly saying taking advantage of people because only because of their fees.

If I have to think of a game that really takes advantage of children, I would say Counter-Strike. Fuck Valve 👀

ltxrtquq@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 11:08 collapse

They’re taking advantage of everyone with their shitty “dev exchange rates”

Also, it’s a bit light to say that they’re stricly saying taking advantage of people because only because of their fees.

I’m honestly not sure what you’re trying to say. I didn’t say the transfer fees were the only way they were taking advantage of people, I just wanted to use the thing you already admitted was predatory and use it to give an example of how roblox is taking advantage of children.

MajesticElevator@lemmy.zip on 25 Apr 12:14 collapse

Yea sure I understand, but I just think that saying “taking advantage of children” implies something way more evil in my head than just having something predatory for everyone. Like something being waaaaay more evil when done on children, an so I don’t really agree that we could say this example is enough to state that roblox takes advantage of children

FIST_FILLET@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 15:24 next collapse

I don’t daily drive macOS anymore

there’s no way a roblox kid is claiming to “daily drive” anything lol

ArsonButCute@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 24 Apr 16:02 next collapse

Hi, 28 here, Roblox came out when I was in middle school, therefore this could be a whole ass Roblox adult, not a Roblox kid.

geneva_convenience@lemmy.ml on 24 Apr 16:05 next collapse

Get off my laaawn

Manifish_Destiny@lemmy.world on 25 Apr 05:57 collapse

Who are you and what have you done with my grandson?

KernelTale@programming.dev on 25 Apr 09:38 collapse

Surpsingly a lot of adults play Roblox. I dislike the game but I was asked multiple times by my older peers to play Roblox.

altphoto@lemmy.today on 25 Apr 06:14 next collapse

Ask? Nah! Grab a bat! This is your computer! Find the fucker and fuck’em up! Give him a taste of hi…oh dude! Not the eye balls! C’mon that’s too muc…that’s a knife! What are you doing! Oh shit! No! C’mon! Not the ball. Oh the entire thing!!! Oh put it in a ziplo…no! Not there! Oh my Jimmy Johnson! My holy jebus! I’m outta here! I don’t know you! Don’t call me!

lonesomeCat@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 10:56 next collapse

But but… User dumb!

Decker108@lemmy.ml on 25 Apr 17:33 collapse

I have to daily drive a Mac for work, and it’s a constant pain. Fortunately, there are signs that the PC world is catching up with Apple hardware, most recently in the form of the Qualcomm Snapdragon X1 series CPUs. The Linux support isn’t there yet, but it’s likely just a matter of time before we too can enjoy excellent battery life and great performance.