Ghouls 'n Ghosts: A Home Port Comparison 🎃
from davetansley@lemmy.world to retrogaming@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 13:35 +0000
https://lemmy.world/post/7543051

Just in time for the spookiest time of year, a game that features not just ghouls, but also ghosts as well. And spooky haunted turtles.

Ghouls 'n Ghosts (Dai Makaimura in Japan) is a classic 1988 Capcom arcade game and sequel to the highly popular Ghosts 'n Goblins. Like its predecessor, you play Arthur, a knight who must save a princess by battling through six spook-filled levels. Along the way, you collect a variety of weapons (sometimes against your will!), beat bosses, avoid wizards in chests, and generally work your way from left to right. You get two hits per life, with your armour disappearing after the first. To help you out, you can collect a golden set of armour that has a charge attack, but you seldom get a chance to use it.

<img alt="The arcade version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/c0KQyQd.png">

The arcade original is just gorgeous in every respect, with masterful pixel art graphics, music that is both spooky and catchy, and controls that feel fluid and responsive. Its levels are varied and interesting, and its bosses challenging. In fact, the whole game is a challenge, with the difficulty ramping right up from the end of level 1. You’re never given a moment to breathe, as zombies continually spill out of the ground and attack you. Gotta keep those quarters coming! And if you pick up the wrong weapon (basically anything but the knife), you’re stuck with it, unless you chance upon a better pick up.

The game was ported all over the place, with varying degrees of success. It came towards the end of the life of the 8-bit micros, so hopes wouldn’t have been high… so how did they do? Actually, not bad. Let’s take a look.

<img alt="The Amstrad version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/GpeZbum.png">

There’s not a lot to pick between the 8-bit and 16-bit micro versions, with each of them suffering similar problems, the worst of which is the limitations of a single-button joystick. This means that firing upwards (an essential part of some levels) is combined with an initial jump, causing you to jump into the enemy you’re trying to dispatch!

The Amstrad suffers all of this, but also some pretty gross push scrolling, which makes it difficult to avoid some enemies. It otherwise looks okay, I guess, with colourful, distinct graphics. It controls fairly well, despite the scrolling limitations, but it is definitely the hardest of the three 8-bit micros. Sound is pretty much non-existent in-game, but it has a lovely title screen rendition of the Ghouls 'n Ghosts theme. Shame it couldn’t play in-game.

Not a bad effort, if a little clunky.

<img alt="The C64 version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/MLgyBjt.png">

The C64 version is distinct from the Amstrad and Spectrum, as is fairly common with games from this era. It has much smaller graphics, but some lovely smooth scrolling. Some of its levels feel incredibly sparse, with very few enemies, which makes it a lot easier than the Amstrad version. Unlike other 8-bit versions, the C64 version has in-game music… though, inexplicably, opts for a custom theme rather than the very familiar Ghouls 'n Ghosts music. It’s very good, but also feels very out of place…

<img alt="The Spectrum version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/FfmJTM7.png">

I start a lot of these Spectrum sections with “you’ll have to trust me on this…”, and this game is no exception. The Spectrum version shares a lot in common with the Amstrad version, but the overall package is a lot slicker. The scrolling is smooth (at least for a Spectrum), the sound is better, and the control feels fluid and “right”. This version, of the three 8-bit micros, feels the most like the arcade. That said, it looks very basic, and is certainly the worst looking of the three, with monochrome graphics that feel sparse and bland. But what did you expect?

Not a bad effort though, and well worth a look for those interested in seeing this ancient machine pushed to its limits. You just need to squint a little…

<img alt="The Amiga version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/kdXbj6U.png">

Sigh. There’s just something deeply disappointing about playing Amiga arcade ports from this era. It’s how a teacher must feel when an obviously gifted student just phones it in and scrapes a D. Amiga Ghouls 'n Ghosts is that kind of port… It looks kind of okay in stills, but when it moves it reveals itself. Slow, jerky scrolling. Lacklustre colours. A small playfield… Like the C64, it goes its own way for music on level 1, and while the tune is suitably spooky, it just never seems to get going.

Overall, its not a terrible port. Its certainly playable. Its just… the Amiga could do so much more, you know?

<img alt="The Master System version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/G7XO144.png">

Over on the consoles, things were a lot better. Starting with the most basic conversion, that of the Sega Master System, we begin to see a lot more of the original’s DNA. The music is here in-game, a plinky plinky chip tune rendition of the original that is perfectly serviceable. The graphics are good and colourful, if a little blocky. It plays really well, and even adds in some light RPG elements in the form of shops in which you can upgrade your equipment. Not sure why this version alone got that addition, but it certainly adds depth.

Overall, I think you’d be happy with this if you were a Master System owner in the late 80s.

<img alt="The Megadrive version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/hKd45NC.png">

Over on the Master System’s big brother, we have perhaps the most impressive port of all (though not the most accurate). Programmed by Yuji Naka (of Sonic The Hedgehog fame), the Megadrive port is extremely competent. Everything is here and incredibly faithful to the original. The music is amazing, managing to sound both faithful and unmistakably Megadrive. The graphics are on point, with just a slightly gaudy palette letting it down slightly. Best of all, it plays incredibly well.

If you want to experience just one “interpretative” port (rather than one of the identical or emulated ports), give this a go.

<img alt="The Supergrafx version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/IASf9CO.png">

A rare spawn - a Supergrafx version! This little known successor to the PC Engine got very few games, and Ghouls 'n Ghosts was perhaps the most famous. Like the Megadrive, it’s a highly faithful and very impressive conversion. Its graphics are perhaps a little more detailed than the Megadrive, with a more refined palette that can sometimes look a little drab. Still, it’s a brilliant conversion, and well worth a look (if you can track it down!)

<img alt="The X68000 version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/JU1eTQF.png">

Onto the Sharp X68000 “port”…

It’s hard to know what to do with this version (and the Playstation one), since they don’t hit the same curiosity triggers as, say, the Amstrad version. It doesn’t really feel like a conversion at all, it feels exactly like the arcade game. And with good reason… the X68000 shared a lot of hardware similarities with the arcade games of the time, and was even used by Capcom as the CPS development machine. So of course it feels great.

But we’re here to see the brave leaps of faith and the tragic failures of ambition… and this ain’t that.

Still, if you want to see a truly arcade perfect port of Ghouls 'n Ghosts, have a look at this…

<img alt="The PS1 version of Ghouls n Ghosts" src="https://i.imgur.com/D7cANg9.png">

… Or this. The PlayStation version is, presumably, using some kind of emulation and a dump of the arcade ROM. As such, I’m tempted to disqualify it… but I wanted to include it purely to point out that even this method doesn’t always guarantee perfection.

There’s something busted about the brightness in this version. It’s way too dark. For my screenshots above, I’ve had to give it a bit of a crank up a notch or two - unscientific, yeah, but otherwise it was very hard to see anything! It could be a problem with my MiSTer, but the few YouTube videos I’ve seen suggest the same problem…

So there you have it. Ghouls 'n Ghosts, a cool game wherever you play it, and a very hard one at that. Try the Megadrive/Genesis port, if you can try just one.

Happy Halloween! 🎃

#retrogaming

LastYearsPumpkin@feddit.ch on 30 Oct 2023 13:54 +0000 next

Great write-up! This was a lot of fun to read and you clearly put in a lot of effort.

Geek_King@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 14:49 +0000 next

I absolutely adored this game on Genesis! I put so much time into bashing my head against it, such a fun game! Thanks for this wonderful write up!

JTStrikesBack@lemm.ee on 30 Oct 2023 14:50 +0000 next

It is a Halloween tradition of mine to play through at least one game in the Ghosts 'n Goblins series every October and the past few years I’ve been branching out into ports of the games that I wasn’t previously familiar with.

This list and write up so absolutely incredible and it’s nice to see someone share a lot of my thoughts on them.

Especially with your

I start a lot of these Spectrum sections with “you’ll have to trust me on this…”

This is pretty much what I have to do, too. “I promise, it looks weird but it’s actually really good” is how I have to explain my love for the ZX Spectrum in general.

TesterJ@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 14:53 +0000 next

Very fun write-up! I love seeing comparisons between ports of older games. There was so much variation back then.

NewNewAccount@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 14:57 +0000 next

Didn’t realize Ghouls n Ghosts didn’t receive an NES or even an SNES version.

Fun and interesting read. Thanks for sharing.

Wrench@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 15:50 +0000

I didn’t even realize Ghost and Goblins was a different game. I figured it was some name license thing because they seemed similar enough that it could be explained by small changes between systems, which wasn’t all that uncommon at the time.

I played a ton of the Sega genesis ghouls n ghosts, and only a little of ghosts and goblins at a friend’s house

hamburglar26@wilbo.tech on 31 Oct 2023 08:46 +0000

This one is a sequel to Ghosts and Goblins. I believe the SNES version that I remember was Super Gouls and Ghosts which I’m not sure is this game on steroids or a totally new game with a confusing title.

davetansley@lemmy.world on 31 Oct 2023 08:59 +0000

I believe Super Ghouls n Ghosts is seen as a sequel to Ghouls n Ghosts.

AlolanYoda@mander.xyz on 30 Oct 2023 15:15 +0000 next

Amazing write-up, I love reading things like these.

I saw that you have similar posts in your profile so I’ll check them all when I have some time!

… Can you subscribe to a person on Lemmy?

Brian_Damage@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 16:11 +0000 next

Love these posts.

In case you haven’t already done Ghosts n Goblins: there was also an utterly horrific ripoff/unofficial port of it on the Amiga called “Belial”.

The only good thing about it was the actually-pretty-spooky-feeling tracker tune cover of Kraftwerk’s “Das Model” as the title/in-game tune, other than that it’s a trashfire.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=gu41M4pmK2s

PipedLinkBot@feddit.rocks on 30 Oct 2023 16:11 +0000 next

Here is an alternative Piped link(s):

https://www.piped.video/watch?v=gu41M4pmK2s

Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.

I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.

davetansley@lemmy.world on 30 Oct 2023 16:15 +0000

Hah! I’d never seen that before! I don’t think it looks too bad :)

I’ve certainly seen worse Amiga ports!

Brian_Damage@lemmy.world on 31 Oct 2023 10:17 +0000

The art is serviceable, if not really taking advantage of what the Amiga can do, but the gameplay is… not great. That person playing has evidently memorised the attack patterns and has mad joystick-waggling skills, because if you don’t you don’t really get past the first squad of bouncing pumpkins XD

Always actually felt like it was released half done. There’s no armour mechanic despite the main character obviously being based on Arthur in underpants-mode, and there are pickups… but there are about two in the whole game and you shoot them rather than walk over them. And they don’t do anything but give you a score boost. There’s also the matter of how the game can be completed in three minutes.

IIRC we got our copy from some cheap Australian mail-order software house and it arrived with the disk bearing a dot-matrix-printed label, I wonder if it’s one of those games where they commissioned the original copy from some kids for a couple hundred dollars? We also had Alpha-1, Caverns of Palle, and Invasion from the same company, and they were similarly C-tier, though they provided some amusement.

knF@lemmy.world on 31 Oct 2023 09:04 +0000 next

I love your reviews, thanks for your great work!

UKFilmNerd@feddit.uk on 31 Oct 2023 21:24 +0000 next

I love these comparison reviews keep 'em coming.

I remember doing my own comparisons back in the day when one budget label would save money by placing the Spectrum game on one side of the tape and the Amstead on the other.

I could take it to a friends house and see if I was jealous or glad depending on how it turned out. I was team Spectrum.

newthrowaway20@lemmy.world on 26 Nov 2023 15:57 +0000

I really appreciate these posts. Thank you for the detailed competitions!