New Scientist — Starfield review: Too much AI-generated content makes for a dull game (archive.ph)
from ylai@lemmy.ml to starfield@lemmy.zip on 21 Sep 2023 08:21
https://lemmy.ml/post/5270108

Original (pay-walled): [newscientist.com/…/mg25934570-700-starfield-revie…]

#starfield

threaded - newest

BradleyUffner@lemmy.world on 21 Sep 2023 11:41 collapse

Generated by an algorithm is not the same as generated by AI.

dan1101@lemm.ee on 21 Sep 2023 12:01 next collapse

Yeah IMO Bethesda totally succeeded in terrain generation. I’ve seen so many impressive scenes. Last night I saw several eclipses and watched a huge gas giant raise up above a moon’s boulder-strewn surface, but the disc was totally black because the sun was behind it. Gradually I saw a crescent gas giant as the sun lit it up from one side.

I think the generation tech is great there maybe should be less content on the planets IMO. Sometimes it feels too crowded and busy even though you’re way out on a remote hostile world.

variants@possumpat.io on 21 Sep 2023 12:31 next collapse

Yeah they need to populate some more and depopulate others, they shouldn’t all feel similar

dan1101@lemm.ee on 21 Sep 2023 14:08 collapse

Yes, variety. Right now they feel like they are all ~800m apart in a grid pattern.

DarkThoughts@kbin.social on 21 Sep 2023 16:08 collapse

They definitely put a lot of work into that and I think it paid off too. The terrain can easily hold up to actual space sims like ED & SC.
POI density can vary greatly, some planets seem to be really packed and others barely have anything at all near your landing site. Though, given the design of the game I think it should not be too empty, because you always want at least "something" near your landing site. If the game had asset streaming for all those space sim features to actually fly around then we'd likely reduce the number of POIs drastically, because we'd be much more mobile.

DoucheBagMcSwag@lemmy.dbzer0.com on 21 Sep 2023 12:14 next collapse

Hey it’s the stupid buzzword that gets you to click

DarkThoughts@kbin.social on 21 Sep 2023 16:03 collapse

I mean, that's what current gen AIs are as well. Though I'd rather not call them AIs either instead, maybe glorified algorithm but that's pretty long.