Bluesky now displays replies by 'hotness'
(mashable.com)
from shoulderoforion@fedia.io to technology@lemmy.world on 30 Nov 00:21
https://fedia.io/m/technology@lemmy.world/t/1491606
from shoulderoforion@fedia.io to technology@lemmy.world on 30 Nov 00:21
https://fedia.io/m/technology@lemmy.world/t/1491606
Not everyone is happy about it being the default.
threaded - newest
To be fair having replies in order of time sucks.
It would be best to let the users to choose their own preference.
You literally can. It’s a setting.
Good
Does it save the setting?
Yes. And furthermore, if you’ve changed the setting in the past, this new default sort change doesn’t override it.
You can though I like it.
I prefer how X orders them based on how much money you give to Elon Musk
Why do you think that sucks? Chronological order makes everything easier to use and navigate
It biases the first repliers
Depends on whether it’s first-on-top or last-on-top…hot/popular biases engagement in obscure ways we can’t see through, which often (always?) ends up favouring trolls and rage-bait.
Weird you’re being voted down.
Who wants the terminally online to be the first five replies to every post? It should sort by op like/boost by default at least
Me. I do. It’s better than the hive mind upvoting some stupid meme reply or some bullshit/misinformation.
So you only see misinformation if professional disinformation employees are paid to reply instantly, which, they are.
I’m not seeing too many professional disinformation employees in here but sure that’s a thing.
X: Old and Busted
BlueSky: New Hotness
I guess I get why 𝕏 changed their short description on the app store to "🔥Blaze your glory" for a while a year ago now.
Cringe af
Has nothing to do with attractiveness. It’s the same “hot” vs “new” etc as any other sort
"Engagement bait" is now the default option. Monetization is the next step.
"Engagement bait" is also the default option on Lemmy, Mbin, etc.
Not sure about Lemmy, but the default option on Mbin is "Hot", which is just chronological order with boosted comments pushed to the top. Boosting is basically just the microblog way of retweeting, and I believe will add an extra point to the score on the Mbin side.
Could be a bit confusing, since Mbin's definition of "hot" is 95% chronological, but Bluesky's definition has more to do with reply/like ratios.
I haven't dived into the source code yet, but while it does seem to weight newness more than e.g. Reddit, it still feels much less than 95% and it's all based on the same principle that upvotes should also determine a bit of what you see. Keep in mind hotness is different from top, an option that Bluesky also has. (I also haven't been able to find which option Bluesky previously defaulted to.)
Huh? Default is Scaled.
That’s for posts, not comments, which is what Bluesky changed.
I was talking about Lemmy
Yeah, by "posts" I meant posts to Lemmy/threads on the home feed. By "comments" I mean the discussion area for each thread.
Any% enshitification speed run GO!
Sooo… You can change the setting.
And?
The fact they make this the default is the issue… The first babysteps to enshitification has now begun.
This, should have made the previous setting the default one
It’s the default for most of Lemmy too.
I really shouldn’t read the news 10 minutes after waking up, my brain was sure this meant that Bluesky was turning into a dating app…
So… . Whatcha doing tonight? ;)
I have a hawt date with my bed, because I’m old and tired ;) :)))
Kinky
Oh, yeah, I’ve been told to tone it down before, my bed and I share too fervent a passion for each other❤️
Everything can be a dating app /s
(this is sadly true)
Hey, as long as they don’t gamify and manipulate things like MatchGroup do with their entire ecosystem, any app would be a better dating app than the dedicated ones…
And the best is still linkedin. Nowhere else do you get desperate woman insisting they want to talk with you.
The heck does that even mean
My guess is timeframe vs active interactions of posts. Like a short term popularity metric? Lemmy has it as a sort option.
They can rank replies any way they want.
they can indeed, i simply do not understand what that would actually entail
So I joined Bluesky over a year ago and have only ever posted a single message "Hi". I've also not liked or commented on any posts. Somehow (especially recently) I am getting followed more and more. I have over a hundred followers now. I'm guessing bots? It's the sudden recent surge over the last couple of months that's interesting.
The fuck??? I like posts all the time, followed 8 people, and have a few posts…I have 3 followers.
My wife is on bluesky and she was telling me yesterday she has had a surge of random followers as well, most likely bots. What she was annoyed about is the block feature doesn’t get them to unfollow you or something. And a portion of the bots are porn repost bots.
You know, they need to make it appear alive and that there are interactions and users so the value raises and people are engaged.
It’s how you make money as a company. For everyone else, mastodon.
Everyone else what? Everyone else that enjoys smooching of free labor? Lol I like Mastodon but this is just a stupid reason to use it.
If you think they’re bots, you can just subscribe to a user-curated block list for bot accounts.
So…like Lemmy?
No? Mine defaults to “newest”
I think it can be configured and it depends on the client to allow it or not.
Funny thing, I had already set my preference to “newest first” and the change was respected after they implemented the new setting.