shortwavesurfer@monero.town
on 12 Dec 2023 12:20
nextcollapse
Thats awsome
thatgirlwasfire@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 12:42
nextcollapse
I wonder if they did these tests using ray tracing or not. On my AMD 7900xt in Cyberpunk, ray tracing under linux is practically unusable levels of performance compared to windows .
vikingtons@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 12:46
nextcollapse
radv is gradually catching up with amdvlk in terms of rtrt perf. could be worth using amdvlk for raytacing for now, though
hal_5700X@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:15
collapse
Safe bet, they didn’t. Seeing they’re talking about the ROG Ally and Lenovo Legion Go.
RickyWars@lemmy.ca
on 12 Dec 2023 12:43
nextcollapse
Cool that average FPS is better but:
The impressive FPS deltas aside, it should be mentioned that, with the exception of Arch Linux, average frame times (measured as 1% lows, in this case) on Linux were generally behind what Windows managed by up to 20%
I feel like worse 1% lows makes this title misleading. Hopefully with time this gap will close.
narc0tic_bird@lemm.ee
on 12 Dec 2023 12:51
collapse
1 % lows are likely a driver thing (Nvidia calls it “Game Ready Drivers”), with Arch you’ll get new drivers (or kernel versions) much earlier, similar to Windows.
iAmTheTot@kbin.social
on 12 Dec 2023 13:45
collapse
... Then why did they get the results that they did in the article?
averyfalken@lemmy.blahaj.zone
on 12 Dec 2023 14:29
collapse
The article specifies arch as an exception to that
can@sh.itjust.works
on 12 Dec 2023 12:49
nextcollapse
OP I love your username
xiffu@kbin.social
on 12 Dec 2023 12:50
nextcollapse
Is fantastic
hal_5700X@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 12:58
nextcollapse
…switching to Linux might be worthwhile for gamers on the move looking to eke out every last drop of performance from the ROG Ally or Lenovo Legion Go.
So they’re talking about the ROG Ally and Lenovo Legion Go not a desktop PC or a laptop. Nice clickbait.
the_q@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:34
nextcollapse
I’m on a desktop running Pop and I bet my system performs better than an equal Windows system. These handhelds are actual PCs, bud.
hal_5700X@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:41
nextcollapse
Okay. But it’s still a clickbait title. Seeing how they said nothing handheld PCs in the title.
The article is referencing a benchmark that was run on desktop hardware so not clickbait. Likely they mentioned the handhelds in the article for ref link revenue.
hal_5700X@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 23:44
collapse
Funny how they didn’t put in the article. Yet, I’m in the wrong thinking it’s about handheld PCs.
It's linked as the source of the article in this link. I would have preferred OP link to it directly, assuming the actual source being in German was a dealbreaker, but it's still linked alongside the TH at the bottom of this one.
I am not sure why you're so adamant about a quote in the article that doesn't say this is about handhelds and getting defensive about a source that is in fact linked in the same article.
For the record, also plainly stated in both articles, the differences in performance are fairly small in all runs, exempting one or two outliers, and seemingly the Windows 1% lows were higher. Despite the Linux fans' overreporting these results, "Proton run good" is not an unexpected result.
hal_5700X@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 06:28
collapse
the article that doesn’t say this is about handhelds
If we are talking about the Notebook Check article. The last paragraph is not helping you. Seeing that’s the only time they talk about hardware in the article. Just helps the confusion.
getting defensive about a source that is in fact linked in the same article.
No, the last paragraph says that these results (seen on a desktop PC) suggest that if you're on lower powered hardware (like a handheld) you may want to ditch the preinstalled Windows and try a Linux install to get a bit more performance.
Which is very debatable on a couple of counts, including the worse 1% lows, the fact that these desktop GPU results may or may not carry over to low TDP AMD APUs and that there's no guarantee that you'll get support for other custom features like the Legion Go's funky detachable controllers. But that's what it's saying, not that the results are about handheld performance.
As for the other thing, man, you're all over this thread being weirdly hostile, All I'm saying is you don't have to be. This isn't a big deal, the article isn't clickbait and nobody is out to get you. There are actually enough things here that are interesting to debate without trying to make this about some weird journalism standards thing. Some of them are even about how shaky some of the reporting is, if that's your angle. It's just... not for the reasons you're getting all worked up about.
prole@sh.itjust.works
on 12 Dec 2023 13:50
collapse
They are just PCs though…? It’s just a different form factor.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:42
nextcollapse
They’re literally just PCs. They aren’t some mysterious thing. They’re using the same architectures a laptop or desktop would.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 14:41
nextcollapse
Linux bros will take anything.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 10:11
collapse
Microsoft bros in denial.
Linux runs windows software faster than Windows can run Windows software.
You don’t need to get upset by that. You don’t owe MS anything. Be happy that more people can game.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 18:20
collapse
Imagine being this tribalistic over an OS. Get a hobby.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 19:24
collapse
Other way around, mate. I’m not the one crying and coming up with excuses and whatabouts when OS A does better than OS B in a benchmark.
Microsoft has done nothing for you. They don’t love you. They’re a 2.8 trillion dollar company. They can get by without you carrying water for them.
Get a hobby.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 21:43
collapse
Literally never said anything of the sort.
Please go outside and get out of this toxic thinking. It’s not healthy for you.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 06:38
collapse
Sure you didn’t.
I hope no more benchmarks offend you in the future.
Bye now.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 10:42
collapse
You got offended. And several others it seems. By a joke, which you then immediately proved to be an accurate description of Linux users.
This is why more people don’t make the switch.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 13:30
collapse
You got offended lol. Take the L. Move on.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 16:45
collapse
You’ve made four comments. Each one reacting to something I never said.
You are literally getting upset by your own shadow at this point.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 18:24
collapse
Are you seriously still crying about this? Jesus. Windows lost in a few benchmarks. It’s not that deep. Take a breath, touch some grass, and move on with your life.
You can still play games just fine. Now you just know it’s slightly faster on Linux. Big whoop. It doesn’t matter. No need to be upset about it.
GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 20:06
collapse
… What?
Evilcoleslaw@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 15:24
collapse
The article talks about those mobile systems, but the actual benchmark on Computerbase tested these on a desktop.
expect more and more of these headlines as linux gaming matures in the next few years.
pedestrian@links.hackliberty.org
on 12 Dec 2023 13:31
nextcollapse
This has been reposted enough to where I’m going to start blocking accounts that continue to post it 😎
the_q@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:32
nextcollapse
Aww I’m sorry you’re stuck in Windows, bud.
pedestrian@links.hackliberty.org
on 12 Dec 2023 13:54
nextcollapse
Lol, you might misunderstand my issue with the constant repost. I get it. Reading comprehension is hard!
iorale@lemmy.dbzer0.com
on 12 Dec 2023 16:01
collapse
I swear most lemmy users will just defend the reposting to death. I’ve been complaining about it since the beginning (huge problem on the lemmynsfw instance) and how people don’t seem to grasp how “federation” works, how everyone sees their damn constant reposts in every instance. Worse part is usually the same user/bot/script posting it everywhere.
Oh an instance is defederated? Well sucks to suck, but I bet at least one of their users will post it there if they have a relevant community.
helenslunch@feddit.nl
on 12 Dec 2023 17:10
collapse
It sounds like you’re referring to cross-posting?
iorale@lemmy.dbzer0.com
on 13 Dec 2023 16:38
collapse
Nope, crossposted posts have a little label that indicates it, I mean users that post the same content to multiple communities (either with a script or manually) and multiple instances which ends up showing multiple times across the feed (either karmawhores or sellers), instead of posting once (to the best fitting community) and then letting that post go up or down the feed and let it federate everywhere.
Crossposting should be modified too because then the post appears twice in the feed, the original and the one marked as crosspost.
ExcursionInversion@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 14:58
collapse
Well shucks, bud
lazynooblet@lazysoci.al
on 12 Dec 2023 15:38
collapse
I think it’s a combination of reposting on Lemmy, multiple communities posting similar stories, and news sites regurgitating results from other sites like it’s fresh news.
pedestrian@links.hackliberty.org
on 12 Dec 2023 20:16
collapse
Agree. My gripe with this article is that I’ve seen it posted on ~6+ communities. I love that Linux is beating windows in gaming benchmarks, but I think the title sensationalizes it the out performance a slight bit.
darganon@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 13:47
nextcollapse
I dual boot arch and windows 11 at home. In World of Warcraft arch is behind, and I haven’t figured out what the problem is. Something just feels off with it. With any luck they’ll continue to improve compatibility. (likely Nvidia driver diff)
prole@sh.itjust.works
on 12 Dec 2023 13:49
nextcollapse
I recently switched to Linux this year (finally), and my experience has been the same.
Not only that, but in some cases, playing a Windows version of a game with Proton seems to work better than the native Linux runtime.
Edit: I use Arch, btw. (lol jk I use EndeavorOS, which is based on Arch)
amen, i love EndeavorOS. i've jettisoned all Windows support in my house and anything that needs Windows gets put into an isolated VLAN that can't talk to anything else. and for the archaic business crap that only has a Windows release, CrossOver is a godsend. same CodeWeavers devs that made Proton and is essentially Wine Premium.
prole@sh.itjust.works
on 12 Dec 2023 15:49
collapse
I’m not an expert in networking stuff… If I am using a Windows 11 laptop (owned by my work) on the same network as my personal laptop while working at home, am I putting my privacy/data/etc. at risk? Should I be sequestering the work laptop in some way?
it wouldn't hurt. i wish my work would just give me a VM to remote into instead of dealing with it on my network, at least in my case all the EDA tools I use are ran on Linux anyway... my last employer put so much spyware "security" software on their work issued laptops that Suricata on my router/firewall would light up like a Christmas tree. no idea what it was trying to do without breaking out Wireshark and analyzing captures, but that's when i said enough is enough... can't be trusted.
BarbecueCowboy@kbin.social
on 12 Dec 2023 14:50
nextcollapse
Anyone have a good explanation on 'Frame Time'? This is the first time I've heard of this term and after some quick googling I feel like I'm not understanding why it's worth caring about.
packetloss@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 14:58
nextcollapse
It’s how long it takes the system to render the next frame. High frame times are no good. Equates to lower average fps, and poor player experience. You also want stable frame times. This equates to smooth gameplay and less “stuttering”. Anything under 20ms is considered good. 10ms and less is great. Anything over 50ms will be perceived by the player in a negative way.
tias@discuss.tchncs.de
on 12 Dec 2023 15:03
nextcollapse
I interpret it as the time taken to render a frame. Unlike FPS which is basically a moving average (or rather 1 divided by the average frame time), frame time is a single data point. Collecting frame times allows you to do things like compute the median or, in this case, the lowest 1% of the frame times. That can give you a better idea of how smooth performance appears to the player, and what the worst-case performance is like.
I'm not surprised at the confusion, because they're using it... not wrong, but very confusingly.
Frame time is literally the time to render a frame. So you'd expect that to be a number of miliseconds per frame and so for lower to be better.
But they're not looking at frametimes, they're looking at 1% lows and expressing that in fps, not in frametimes. So yeah, confusing.
For the record, the reson why the term is becoming popular is that there are now widespread visualizations that will give you a line of your frametimes in a graph so you can see if the line is flat or spiky. You've probably seen it on the Steam Deck or performance analysis videos or whatever. The idea is that all frametimes being consistent is better than high fps but low 1% or 0.1% low. So stable 60fps can look better than spiky 90fps and so on.
ls64@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 15:16
nextcollapse
I still can’t get anything to run consistently in Linux after 10 years, and many, many distros.
Timber born and Raft currently never open, no matter what.
I a huge Linux user but the gamin experience has always been so finicky for me and no matter how much I try it’s still unattainable.
And even when they run its with a lot of configution and tinkering unless it has native support. I have no issue with that but I’m so frustrated my experience with this seems so diffent than what everyone else is having.
I want to delete my windows partition and it still feels so far away.
Amends1782@lemmy.ca
on 12 Dec 2023 15:28
nextcollapse
I’d be happy to help if you’d like
I can play 90% or more of my library on Linux. Basically, if its in steam it’s a cake walk. I recommend something like Mint cinammon or pop_os all you need is proton really. I can’t run games with certain anti cheat like tarkov cause the anti cheat devs don’t support Linux
Running mint right now, went back to basics after a stint with majaro.
I appreciate the offer but for now the windows distro stays and every few months I will try again.
I know so many people have such a seamless experience. That is what makes it way more frustrating.
YMMV of course but I was playing Timberborn just the other day on Mint, on an Nvidia card, through Heroic. Proton seems to have been a gamechanger. I have just made my first steps into switching my daily driver myself. I may have been lucky but all the games I have wanted to play have worked so far. I also have a Steam Deck, which is what has encouraged me that it may be possible.
This. While the experience for Gaming on linux is still not perfect, or as easy as install and play, Heroic is a good start. It still requires configuration and many hidden configs are not always obvious for the user, but I managed to run every game I threw at it flawlessly so far. All AAA games, and games from 2000 (Hitman, C&C games, Jazz Jackrabbit etc…), GoW, Cyberpunk, Hogwarts, etc. On a RTx 2070.
Telodzrum@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 21:50
collapse
Between Steam, Lutris, and Heroic I can run every game I’ve tried on Linux.
MisterNeon@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 16:55
nextcollapse
Damn, I was thinking about switching but I play alot of Timberborn.
nutsack@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 17:10
nextcollapse
this game is actually fun? what would you compare it to?
MisterNeon@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 17:56
collapse
It’s Rimworld mixed with Sim City in an amusement water park.
Evrala@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 17:29
nextcollapse
I play quite a bit of timberborn, worked just fine. Had some sound issues but changing to proton experimental fixed them.
InvisibleShoe@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 03:28
collapse
I’ve got >500hours in Timberborn on Ubuntu. Runs flawlessly and never had an issue.
dewritoninja@pawb.social
on 12 Dec 2023 17:24
nextcollapse
What have you been doing. Cause for me it’s just install steam enable proton and install pretty much any game on my library. Or install lutris login to my accounts and play epic games / gog games. It literally just works
ls64@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 22:23
nextcollapse
I know this is a very common experience, but for me it fails. The list is too long but belive me I’ve tried it.
It’s probably some weird driver issue or some thing I use for x y or z that conflicts. Who knows.
iamtherealwalrus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 10:19
collapse
Let me know when you get Witcher 2 to run on Linux. With some tinkering and magic settings, it can run. But it crashes so often it is bordering unplayable, using several different versions of Proton in Steam and Pop! Os.
dewritoninja@pawb.social
on 13 Dec 2023 13:10
collapse
I don’t own it but according to protondb it has native support for Linux
iamtherealwalrus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 15:46
collapse
That’s fine. But it crashes constantly on Linux, rarely on Windows. Point being that not all games run fine on Linux.
TheBlackLounge@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 16:10
nextcollapse
(They were not serious)
dogslayeggs@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 16:37
collapse
That’s the point they were trying to make. It was a facetious question.
SquirtleHermit@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 16:07
nextcollapse
About the same as Spiderman 2 or Ghost of Tsushima on Windows.
agraves@lm.possum.city
on 12 Dec 2023 16:08
collapse
you mean the rootkits that won’t run on Linux?
Toribor@corndog.social
on 12 Dec 2023 16:10
collapse
When did ‘rootkit’ come to be a generic term for invasive software? Rootkits are a specific type of thing.
lemann@lemmy.one
on 12 Dec 2023 16:57
nextcollapse
Anticheats that run in the NT kernel may as well be described as rootkits, especially as they aren’t transparent about exactly what they’re doing. Then there’s the question of what happens if they get compromised
agraves@lm.possum.city
on 12 Dec 2023 17:16
nextcollapse
Vanguard, BattlEye, EasyAntiCheat, Ricochet, etc… all run in the Windows Kernel and most, if not all, have the functionality to run arbitrary code, so might as well class them as rootkits.
KairuByte@lemmy.dbzer0.com
on 13 Dec 2023 01:55
nextcollapse
Because “rootkit” sounds more ominous and scary than “kernel level anticheat” and the communities complaining about such things aren’t known to keep hyperbole to a minimum. Gotta push that FUD.
This article for instance, using language that insinuates a huge gap in performance between the Linux distros and windows, when it’s a 6% difference between the best and the worst, on one set of hardware.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 13:43
collapse
If it has kernel level access and can run arbitrary code, that’s a rootkit.
It’s absolutely valid to call these systems rootkits.
Thorny_Insight@lemm.ee
on 12 Dec 2023 16:19
nextcollapse
Since Steam stops working on Win7 in january I was forced to update the OS and I went with Ubuntu since the newer windows seem like plain garbage and spyware. Installing the OS was a huge hassle and getting DayZ to run on it wasn’t without an issue either but it works now and the performance seems to be about the same. I only use the Linux machine for occasional gaming so it’ll do but I’m not sure if I could daily drive it. Everything seems to need you to do something in terminal which I understand nothing about and aren’t interested in learning.
TimeSquirrel@kbin.social
on 12 Dec 2023 22:25
nextcollapse
You may be more interested in the Steam Deck, a ready-to-go Linux gaming system that doesn't require terminal proficiency. Just turn it on and play like a Nintendo Switch.
Thorny_Insight@lemm.ee
on 13 Dec 2023 05:43
collapse
I don’t feel like buying yet another device when I already have a decent gaming rig. I’ve got a PS4 too but I never use it because I prefer using a mouse and keyboard.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 13:52
collapse
Installing it was a hassle? May I ask how? In my experience it’s windows that’s a hassle to install. The non-descript error messages, it randomly rebooting like 6 times during installation was pretty jarring, it takes ages even for an NVME drive.
On Linux it’s generally next next username password next next and we’re done. Maybe on a laptop you’ll need to install WiFi drivers manually if it’s a crappy Broadcom WiFi adapter, but that’s not been an issue for years I don’t think.
And as for needing to do stuff in terminal I don’t really see that either. Everything seems to be accessible in the GUI, I can’t really think of any normal task that requires the terminal
Thorny_Insight@lemm.ee
on 13 Dec 2023 14:12
collapse
Every time I tried installing, it failed in some new way. It wasn’t consistent so I had no idea how to troubleshoot it. It wasn’t asking which hard drive to install it onto, the installer was being extremely slow and unresponsive, the non-safe graphics option wasn’t working at all… I basically just had to abort the installation and start again like 10 times. What finally made it work was putting a different version of Ubuntu on the boot USB and using a different USB port and stick along with the safe graphics istallation. Even now it’s still giving me some TOCBLOCK error on boot, but everything seems to work fine anyways.
I can’t really think of any normal task that requires the terminal
This was the quide for installing drivers for my wifi adapter for example. Maybe there is easier way but each one I found needed you to use terminal. Even the manual that came with the wifi stick.
i just saw this for the first time and it brought me joy
OfficerBribe@lemm.ee
on 12 Dec 2023 17:30
nextcollapse
1 day cannot pass without this article getting reposted across various communities.
Hawk@lemmy.dbzer0.com
on 12 Dec 2023 17:32
nextcollapse
Yeah, these are getting really annoying.
Cethin@lemmy.zip
on 12 Dec 2023 21:56
nextcollapse
As someone on Linux, and who thinks performance is generally slightly better on my machine after switching, I totally agree. This post has been old for a while now. Get some more data and then post that new thing or stop posting it.
GarytheSnail@programming.dev
on 12 Dec 2023 22:40
nextcollapse
I swear people just scroll through lemmy, see a post they like and then think to themselves, “this is cool, I should post this on lemmy!”
troyunrau@lemmy.ca
on 13 Dec 2023 07:05
nextcollapse
It’s okay. Lemmy isn’t a wiki. Content is organized temporally. Imagine these conversations as bar conversations (just because one group had a conversation one night, doesn’t mean another group can’t repeat it the next). If you are annoyed that the algo keeps giving you the same stuff, sort by All and New Comments and you’ll find niche communities to subscribe to.
A Lemmy option to hide posts of links already red in another post would be neat. (First time I see this one though)
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 12 Dec 2023 21:07
nextcollapse
Testing done on specific hardware and not a broad spectrum of machines is as relevant as asking one person their political opinion and saying that applies to their whole nation.
RealFknNito@lemmy.world
on 12 Dec 2023 22:43
collapse
Well sure but rephrased it’s just “Three Linux distros that embarrass Windows 11 in gaming performance.” which to me, is equally interesting.
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 00:37
nextcollapse
“on that one specific machine.”
You’re missing that part from your premise and it’s the important one.
Notice how they didn’t use one with an Nvidia GPU… Or even hardware released this year either…
Edit: Aaaw, I made you angwy and you downvoted me :(
AProfessional@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 04:16
nextcollapse
The Nvidia drivers perform fine generally but it would be nice to verify it.
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 09:05
collapse
It’s funny because you say that and at the same time it’s the first question asked when someone has a hard time gaming on their Linux setup, “Nvidia GPU?”, even in this thread it’s come up.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 10:13
collapse
The issue isn’t performance, it’s Nvidia’s unstable drivers.
E: fuck me, are people stupid? Performance and stability are not the same thing.
Performance on Nvidia cards on Linux is fine. The issue is the bizarre issues you have like multi-monitor weirdness or adaptive refresh rate not working properly. Nvidia’s drivers need kinks worked out but they aren’t slower.
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 10:39
nextcollapse
You realise that not having access to stable drivers is a performance issue because it means games don’t run properly or at all?
“The issue isn’t my bike, it’s the bent wheels on it!”
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 11:37
collapse
Wow you’re *incredibly* smart.
I certainly am smarter than the people who base their conclusion of an OS performance being better than another OS’ on a test made on a single hardware setup.
It’s also very funny that when people say they have a hard time making games run on Linux and they mention that they have an Nvidia GPU the first reaction is “Oh yeah, that’s why” and then they’re told to try whatever voodoo magic is in season at the moment to make it run properly but you’re here saying “Oh no, there’s no problem in game!” Yeah, because the problem is actually loading the game inthe first place so there can’t be any issues IN it if you can’t get in!
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 13:45
collapse
I don’t know why you’re not upset that they present it as a fact when they only tested on one machine with AMD hardware to come to a general conclusion as if it applied to all hardware.
Irrelevant to someone that wants their game to run.
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 13:00
collapse
I didn’t say otherwise. We were talking performance, not stability, that’s why I said the word performance, then said Nvidia’s drivers were unstable.
Understand? Performance means performance and stability means stability. I can appreciate that might be hard to grasp, but they’re different words for a reason, and that reason is they mean different things.
I don’t know why I bother talking to morons on Lemmy who deliberately misinterpret what people say and use that as a gotcha. You’re not smart for using a straw man argument.
inverted_deflector@startrek.website
on 13 Dec 2023 14:37
collapse
Nvidia isnt so bad if you’re on a stable distro it supports and using x(though Ive heard wayland support is improving for it). On rolling or more cutting edge distros where the kernel is likely to change every few weeks and major DE versions might ship that proprietary driver will hurt.
That said while amd is generally better on linux for this reason it’s worth mentioning that it has two huge flaws:
1.Its not perfect like the fans mention. As someone who owned a 3500u and 6650u apu life under amd isnt always sunny. 3500u had a kernel regression for about half a year that prevented the cpu from idling and rembrant apus have an issue where the whole system locks up which seems to come and go(feels like it’s gone for now but Ive thought that before). Desktop gpus are better, but they still did suffer from driver bugs. I think my experience with my 5600xt was better than windows fans had for that generation, but it was not entirely stable and I did suffer from many kernel panics and system freezes. A few mesa and kernel releases fixed that, but it wasnt perfectly smooth. In addition to that no hdmi 2.1 support which is fine unless you game using your nice oled tv because no tvs come with display port. Proprietary drivers do allow for supporting some of the more obnoxious features that arent allowed.
It can vary gpu/cpu to gpu/cpu for how fresh your software will need to be, but generally newer hardware needs very new kernels just for basic support and it may need a few more releases to get stable or good. So if you want to just sit back with ubutnu LTS or debian you need to make sure the release cycle lines up with support for your hardware. The other end of the spectrum is that being on a bleeding or cutting edge distro can mean stability issues and regressions. So for example a month or three ago fedora pushed a kernel update that had a regression where my 6800xt gpu wouldnt clock up when utilized so gaming framerates tanked and retroarch shaders were choking up. I could just use the old kernel but I had to make sure that the kernel updates didnt bump it away. Also an entire point release and several releases after that before the bug was fixed.
So while there is a lot of pro amd comments in the linux world and its worth acknowledging that the open source drivers are generally good it’s not perfect and the grass isnt always greener.
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 18:02
collapse
Just from that comment we can see how far from mainstream adoption Linux is for gaming… You really need to want to understand how things work to fix things that might not work natively. Not every gamer wants to be super knowledgeable about computers, most just want to play games. Heck, I’m very good with computers and I know that what little time I have to play games I don’t want to spend trying to make them work…
adrian783@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 00:40
collapse
article title: windows DEAD LAST!
also in the same article: “… When it comes to FPS, the overall leader in testing was Nobara Linux, with Arch Linux and Pop!_OS trailing by 1–5%. Windows 11, however, was only 6% behind Nobara Linux. So, **there isn’t a massive performance delta here, **”
thesilverpig@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 01:17
nextcollapse
gaming and the abundance of software and third party support and tutorials on windows is why I haven’t taken the dive to linux yet. So yeah, if linux does gaming as well or better my migration is more and more likely.
I’m gonna be that Linux bro and tell you to switch 😁 I made the full switch earlier this year and I’ve been amazed by how good proton is. There’s only been one game I couldn’t get to run until I did by installing some Microsoft VC runtime. Give it a shot! You just might be pleasantly surprised as I was.
adrian783@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 01:19
collapse
is the point of article not to stroke the ego of the Linux absolutists that have some weird chip on their shoulders when it comes to video games?
Kecessa@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 02:28
collapse
No it hasn’t, some games run better on the hardware tested when running Linux, some games don’t work at all on Linux whereas all games run on Windows.
Come back when they test multiple machines running various hardware and when they compare the experience setting up said machines to actually run the games.
You’re exactly the person this article was written for, someone who wants their opinion reinforced because they won’t take the time to analyze the data presented.
They… accepted that they’re not killing Linux, yet. Back in the 2000s, before Azure, they felt quite threated by Linux and ‘Microsoft Linux’ was a joke. The then-CEO Steve Ballmer called Linux a ‘cancer’.
LillyPip@lemmy.ca
on 13 Dec 2023 02:42
nextcollapse
I’ve been out of the industry for a while, but unless Windows was completely rewritten from the ground up in the last 5 years, this doesn’t surprise me. That OS has always been a hot, bloated mess. And no, I’m not a Linux bro. I use another heavily commercialised OS that doesn’t run Windows because I no longer have the energy to care.
An OS written on Unix can outperform Windows? I’m shocked.
sturmblast@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 03:38
nextcollapse
News flash, Windows is garbage.
firefly@neon.nightbulb.net
on 13 Dec 2023 10:24
collapse
egeres@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 15:09
nextcollapse
I’m not deep on how the core of an OS works, but to my understanding, the kernel of linux should be more robust and reliable, shouldn’t it always be performing better than windows on the same hardware?
Where could I read information on the things that hinder performance on linux, does anybody have any educational resources?
On Linux, you run windows programs through wine, which is an additional layer that can theoretically slow down the program.
Also, windows supports certain constructs like io completion ports or WaitForMultipleObjects that historically haven’t been emulated efficiently on Linux since it lacked comparable primitives, although those specific ones have been greatly improved in recent years with io_uring and FUTEX_WAIT_MULTIPLE.
There have been similar issues with direct3D since wine used to have to emulate it in OpenGL, but with vkd3d, wine has more opportunities to efficiently implement the d3d apis.
Basically wine being slower was the norm until quite recently.
ItsGatorSeason@lemm.ee
on 13 Dec 2023 23:29
collapse
Thanks to the one crazy guy valve contracts making proton… It’s crazy how his work basically made gaming on Linux a thing. But yeah the other major thing, which you mentioned, is games/game engines using directX9, directX10 and directX11 (the windows 3d graphics libraries) have their API/rendering calls mapped directly to Vulkan. Those APIs were easier to use but from my understanding (I’m no graphics expert) didn’t have the ability to use the full potential of the hardware, and basically had a single channel/thread to the GPU. DirectX12 and Vulkan are much more difficult to use, and some games have used them horribly such that DX11 performs better than DX12, but a good implementation can take advantage of multichannel/multithreaded communication to the GPU allowing much faster and efficient data transfer. They allow the engine programmer to have much more control of the hardware. So vkd3d/proton gives that massive performance impact by mapping the graphics calls from an older API to a newer one. I have not looked into how it’s implemented but it’s basically magic. This was the main reason why wine kinda sucked for gaming before proton.
The Windows scheduler is actually pretty decent, it’s been a few years since I looked into it but I think Windows soft-real time scheduling was better than the one Linux used, though idk if games even use that.
The thing holding Linux back, mostly just for online games with anticheat, is anticheat developers reluctance to port to Linux. I believe do to the differences between users pace and kernel space on Windows VS Linux makes bypassing the anticheat on Linux much easier, or the anticheat can use the same tricks that it does on windows.
Xideta@ani.social
on 13 Dec 2023 15:45
nextcollapse
I’ve heard that Linux’s task scheduler is just much better than windows’, so it kinda makes sense that all would beat Windows.
Mandy@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 18:26
nextcollapse
I keep hearing and seeing from seemingly everyone that Linux gaming is better basically every month, how it keeps improving and stuff (like the article here)
But for me personally it never did in the last 5 years, whenever I try to step out if emulation and back to windows exlusove games? Its like 5 bullet Russian roulette, if it works at all and doesn’t stop working for inexlicitly no reason
What are yall doing to actually make things work somewhat reasonable (default lutris, proton, or ge has never even renowtly worked how well for me, at all)
Cralder@feddit.nu
on 13 Dec 2023 18:50
nextcollapse
For me default proton “just works” usually. But I play a lot of indie games
snekerpimp@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 22:02
nextcollapse
Modern Linux kernel and steam with proton, and in a few instances lutris with wine. Unless it has anticheet, it’ll play pretty well.
Mandy@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 22:34
collapse
what black magic are you using to make them work
snekerpimp@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 22:50
collapse
AMD 7600x and 6700xt, Debian 12… proton, wine, keyboard and mouse? Been using it no problem with cyberpunk and Starfield for a few months now. Play Diablo 4 and overwatch with my kids. Been gaming on Linux for almost 4 years now. It HAS come a very very long way since the steamdeck was launched though. Proton and lutris are the glue that hold it all together.
Mandy@sh.itjust.works
on 13 Dec 2023 23:03
collapse
idk what kinda glue you are thinking about, but it aint the one im seeing
gtx 1660 super here and distro agnostic for me, same problems all around
cyberpunk, a slideshow at best, tried several times and several configs
diablo 4 (got it from a friend), never launched, cause battlnet never works
snekerpimp@lemmy.world
on 13 Dec 2023 23:09
nextcollapse
I’m convinced it’s my AMD graphics that are making things so easy for me. I have had no issues at all with their drivers. Ran arch with no issues for a few years, now Debian for a few months. Have never had an nvidia card.
NixDev@programming.dev
on 13 Dec 2023 23:36
collapse
I have been using an all AMD system for years on Linux and haven’t had any issues. Some coworkers with Nvidia graphics said it was a nightmare. So it must be the AMD drivers
jodanlime@midwest.social
on 13 Dec 2023 23:26
collapse
I have over 200 hours in cyberpunk on Linux. The gog version is a little bit more work to setup the steam version. If you have it on steam, and have steam installed natively (not inside wine) it should work assuming you have the correct GPU drivers installed.
I’ve always had weird, buggy shit with Nvidias Linux drivers. AMD is pretty great though.
You could try an open source game like xonotic that supports Linux to test as well.
Treczoks@lemmy.world
on 14 Dec 2023 08:10
collapse
The only issues left with Windows-Only games is their crippeling-for-purpose anti-cheat code. Anything else works better on Linux.
So the question is whether to support those BDSM anti-cheat games, or get a better gaming experience.
It actually works flawlessly, except for those windows only games of those ones with anticheat bullshit. Especial on AMD, as all the drivers are baked into the kernel and it’s literally plug and play.
threaded - newest
Thats awsome
I wonder if they did these tests using ray tracing or not. On my AMD 7900xt in Cyberpunk, ray tracing under linux is practically unusable levels of performance compared to windows .
radv is gradually catching up with amdvlk in terms of rtrt perf. could be worth using amdvlk for raytacing for now, though
Safe bet, they didn’t. Seeing they’re talking about the ROG Ally and Lenovo Legion Go.
Cool that average FPS is better but:
I feel like worse 1% lows makes this title misleading. Hopefully with time this gap will close.
1 % lows are likely a driver thing (Nvidia calls it “Game Ready Drivers”), with Arch you’ll get new drivers (or kernel versions) much earlier, similar to Windows.
... Then why did they get the results that they did in the article?
The article specifies arch as an exception to that
OP I love your username
Is fantastic
So they’re talking about the ROG Ally and Lenovo Legion Go not a desktop PC or a laptop. Nice clickbait.
I’m on a desktop running Pop and I bet my system performs better than an equal Windows system. These handhelds are actual PCs, bud.
Okay. But it’s still a clickbait title. Seeing how they said nothing handheld PCs in the title.
The article is referencing a benchmark that was run on desktop hardware so not clickbait. Likely they mentioned the handhelds in the article for ref link revenue.
Funny how they didn’t put in the article. Yet, I’m in the wrong thinking it’s about handheld PCs.
Nope, from the Tom's Hardware source:
It's still relevant that this was not running on a Nvidia GPU, IMO, but not about handheld PCs.
So you have to going to another article to get the full story. gg notebookcheck.net.
Also can you link the Tom’s Hardware article.
It's linked as the source of the article in this link. I would have preferred OP link to it directly, assuming the actual source being in German was a dealbreaker, but it's still linked alongside the TH at the bottom of this one.
I am not sure why you're so adamant about a quote in the article that doesn't say this is about handhelds and getting defensive about a source that is in fact linked in the same article.
For the record, also plainly stated in both articles, the differences in performance are fairly small in all runs, exempting one or two outliers, and seemingly the Windows 1% lows were higher. Despite the Linux fans' overreporting these results, "Proton run good" is not an unexpected result.
If we are talking about the Notebook Check article. The last paragraph is not helping you. Seeing that’s the only time they talk about hardware in the article. Just helps the confusion.
All I did is ask for a link.
No, the last paragraph says that these results (seen on a desktop PC) suggest that if you're on lower powered hardware (like a handheld) you may want to ditch the preinstalled Windows and try a Linux install to get a bit more performance.
Which is very debatable on a couple of counts, including the worse 1% lows, the fact that these desktop GPU results may or may not carry over to low TDP AMD APUs and that there's no guarantee that you'll get support for other custom features like the Legion Go's funky detachable controllers. But that's what it's saying, not that the results are about handheld performance.
As for the other thing, man, you're all over this thread being weirdly hostile, All I'm saying is you don't have to be. This isn't a big deal, the article isn't clickbait and nobody is out to get you. There are actually enough things here that are interesting to debate without trying to make this about some weird journalism standards thing. Some of them are even about how shaky some of the reporting is, if that's your angle. It's just... not for the reasons you're getting all worked up about.
They are just PCs though…? It’s just a different form factor.
They’re literally just PCs. They aren’t some mysterious thing. They’re using the same architectures a laptop or desktop would.
Out of touch comment.
Handheld PCs are PCs.
Linux bros will take anything.
Microsoft bros in denial.
Linux runs windows software faster than Windows can run Windows software.
You don’t need to get upset by that. You don’t owe MS anything. Be happy that more people can game.
Imagine being this tribalistic over an OS. Get a hobby.
Other way around, mate. I’m not the one crying and coming up with excuses and whatabouts when OS A does better than OS B in a benchmark.
Microsoft has done nothing for you. They don’t love you. They’re a 2.8 trillion dollar company. They can get by without you carrying water for them.
Get a hobby.
Literally never said anything of the sort.
Please go outside and get out of this toxic thinking. It’s not healthy for you.
Sure you didn’t.
I hope no more benchmarks offend you in the future.
Bye now.
You got offended. And several others it seems. By a joke, which you then immediately proved to be an accurate description of Linux users.
This is why more people don’t make the switch.
You got offended lol. Take the L. Move on.
You’ve made four comments. Each one reacting to something I never said.
You are literally getting upset by your own shadow at this point.
Are you seriously still crying about this? Jesus. Windows lost in a few benchmarks. It’s not that deep. Take a breath, touch some grass, and move on with your life.
You can still play games just fine. Now you just know it’s slightly faster on Linux. Big whoop. It doesn’t matter. No need to be upset about it.
… What?
The article talks about those mobile systems, but the actual benchmark on Computerbase tested these on a desktop.
Ryzen 7 5800X
Scythe Mugen 5 cooler
Asus ROG Strix B550-A Gaming
32BG DDR4-3600-RAM (CL18-22-22-44)
Sapphire RX 6700 XT Nitro+
Tested @ 1080p 144Hz, Freesync Off
expect more and more of these headlines as linux gaming matures in the next few years.
This has been reposted enough to where I’m going to start blocking accounts that continue to post it 😎
Aww I’m sorry you’re stuck in Windows, bud.
Lol, you might misunderstand my issue with the constant repost. I get it. Reading comprehension is hard!
I swear most lemmy users will just defend the reposting to death. I’ve been complaining about it since the beginning (huge problem on the lemmynsfw instance) and how people don’t seem to grasp how “federation” works, how everyone sees their damn constant reposts in every instance. Worse part is usually the same user/bot/script posting it everywhere.
Oh an instance is defederated? Well sucks to suck, but I bet at least one of their users will post it there if they have a relevant community.
It sounds like you’re referring to cross-posting?
Nope, crossposted posts have a little label that indicates it, I mean users that post the same content to multiple communities (either with a script or manually) and multiple instances which ends up showing multiple times across the feed (either karmawhores or sellers), instead of posting once (to the best fitting community) and then letting that post go up or down the feed and let it federate everywhere.
Crossposting should be modified too because then the post appears twice in the feed, the original and the one marked as crosspost.
Well shucks, bud
I think it’s a combination of reposting on Lemmy, multiple communities posting similar stories, and news sites regurgitating results from other sites like it’s fresh news.
Agree. My gripe with this article is that I’ve seen it posted on ~6+ communities. I love that Linux is beating windows in gaming benchmarks, but I think the title sensationalizes it the out performance a slight bit.
I dual boot arch and windows 11 at home. In World of Warcraft arch is behind, and I haven’t figured out what the problem is. Something just feels off with it. With any luck they’ll continue to improve compatibility. (likely Nvidia driver diff)
I recently switched to Linux this year (finally), and my experience has been the same.
Not only that, but in some cases, playing a Windows version of a game with Proton seems to work better than the native Linux runtime.
Edit: I use Arch, btw. (lol jk I use EndeavorOS, which is based on Arch)
amen, i love EndeavorOS. i've jettisoned all Windows support in my house and anything that needs Windows gets put into an isolated VLAN that can't talk to anything else. and for the archaic business crap that only has a Windows release, CrossOver is a godsend. same CodeWeavers devs that made Proton and is essentially Wine Premium.
I’m not an expert in networking stuff… If I am using a Windows 11 laptop (owned by my work) on the same network as my personal laptop while working at home, am I putting my privacy/data/etc. at risk? Should I be sequestering the work laptop in some way?
it wouldn't hurt. i wish my work would just give me a VM to remote into instead of dealing with it on my network, at least in my case all the EDA tools I use are ran on Linux anyway... my last employer put so much
spyware"security" software on their work issued laptops that Suricata on my router/firewall would light up like a Christmas tree. no idea what it was trying to do without breaking out Wireshark and analyzing captures, but that's when i said enough is enough... can't be trusted.Anyone have a good explanation on 'Frame Time'? This is the first time I've heard of this term and after some quick googling I feel like I'm not understanding why it's worth caring about.
It’s how long it takes the system to render the next frame. High frame times are no good. Equates to lower average fps, and poor player experience. You also want stable frame times. This equates to smooth gameplay and less “stuttering”. Anything under 20ms is considered good. 10ms and less is great. Anything over 50ms will be perceived by the player in a negative way.
I interpret it as the time taken to render a frame. Unlike FPS which is basically a moving average (or rather 1 divided by the average frame time), frame time is a single data point. Collecting frame times allows you to do things like compute the median or, in this case, the lowest 1% of the frame times. That can give you a better idea of how smooth performance appears to the player, and what the worst-case performance is like.
I'm not surprised at the confusion, because they're using it... not wrong, but very confusingly.
Frame time is literally the time to render a frame. So you'd expect that to be a number of miliseconds per frame and so for lower to be better.
But they're not looking at frametimes, they're looking at 1% lows and expressing that in fps, not in frametimes. So yeah, confusing.
For the record, the reson why the term is becoming popular is that there are now widespread visualizations that will give you a line of your frametimes in a graph so you can see if the line is flat or spiky. You've probably seen it on the Steam Deck or performance analysis videos or whatever. The idea is that all frametimes being consistent is better than high fps but low 1% or 0.1% low. So stable 60fps can look better than spiky 90fps and so on.
I still can’t get anything to run consistently in Linux after 10 years, and many, many distros. Timber born and Raft currently never open, no matter what. I a huge Linux user but the gamin experience has always been so finicky for me and no matter how much I try it’s still unattainable. And even when they run its with a lot of configution and tinkering unless it has native support. I have no issue with that but I’m so frustrated my experience with this seems so diffent than what everyone else is having. I want to delete my windows partition and it still feels so far away.
I’d be happy to help if you’d like I can play 90% or more of my library on Linux. Basically, if its in steam it’s a cake walk. I recommend something like Mint cinammon or pop_os all you need is proton really. I can’t run games with certain anti cheat like tarkov cause the anti cheat devs don’t support Linux
Running mint right now, went back to basics after a stint with majaro. I appreciate the offer but for now the windows distro stays and every few months I will try again. I know so many people have such a seamless experience. That is what makes it way more frustrating.
YMMV of course but I was playing Timberborn just the other day on Mint, on an Nvidia card, through Heroic. Proton seems to have been a gamechanger. I have just made my first steps into switching my daily driver myself. I may have been lucky but all the games I have wanted to play have worked so far. I also have a Steam Deck, which is what has encouraged me that it may be possible.
This. While the experience for Gaming on linux is still not perfect, or as easy as install and play, Heroic is a good start. It still requires configuration and many hidden configs are not always obvious for the user, but I managed to run every game I threw at it flawlessly so far. All AAA games, and games from 2000 (Hitman, C&C games, Jazz Jackrabbit etc…), GoW, Cyberpunk, Hogwarts, etc. On a RTx 2070.
Between Steam, Lutris, and Heroic I can run every game I’ve tried on Linux.
Damn, I was thinking about switching but I play alot of Timberborn.
this game is actually fun? what would you compare it to?
It’s Rimworld mixed with Sim City in an amusement water park.
( •_•)>⌐■-■
It’s also technically a post apocalypse setting.
thanks im gonna try sexing with it
I play quite a bit of timberborn, worked just fine. Had some sound issues but changing to proton experimental fixed them.
I’ve got >500hours in Timberborn on Ubuntu. Runs flawlessly and never had an issue.
What have you been doing. Cause for me it’s just install steam enable proton and install pretty much any game on my library. Or install lutris login to my accounts and play epic games / gog games. It literally just works
I know this is a very common experience, but for me it fails. The list is too long but belive me I’ve tried it. It’s probably some weird driver issue or some thing I use for x y or z that conflicts. Who knows.
Let me know when you get Witcher 2 to run on Linux. With some tinkering and magic settings, it can run. But it crashes so often it is bordering unplayable, using several different versions of Proton in Steam and Pop! Os.
I don’t own it but according to protondb it has native support for Linux
That’s fine. But it crashes constantly on Linux, rarely on Windows. Point being that not all games run fine on Linux.
.
Nvidia GPU?
What do the performance metrics look like for the games that won’t run on Linux?
.
(They were not serious)
That’s the point they were trying to make. It was a facetious question.
About the same as Spiderman 2 or Ghost of Tsushima on Windows.
you mean the rootkits that won’t run on Linux?
When did ‘rootkit’ come to be a generic term for invasive software? Rootkits are a specific type of thing.
Anticheats that run in the NT kernel may as well be described as rootkits, especially as they aren’t transparent about exactly what they’re doing. Then there’s the question of what happens if they get compromised
Vanguard, BattlEye, EasyAntiCheat, Ricochet, etc… all run in the Windows Kernel and most, if not all, have the functionality to run arbitrary code, so might as well class them as rootkits.
Because “rootkit” sounds more ominous and scary than “kernel level anticheat” and the communities complaining about such things aren’t known to keep hyperbole to a minimum. Gotta push that FUD.
This article for instance, using language that insinuates a huge gap in performance between the Linux distros and windows, when it’s a 6% difference between the best and the worst, on one set of hardware.
If it has kernel level access and can run arbitrary code, that’s a rootkit.
It’s absolutely valid to call these systems rootkits.
Since Steam stops working on Win7 in january I was forced to update the OS and I went with Ubuntu since the newer windows seem like plain garbage and spyware. Installing the OS was a huge hassle and getting DayZ to run on it wasn’t without an issue either but it works now and the performance seems to be about the same. I only use the Linux machine for occasional gaming so it’ll do but I’m not sure if I could daily drive it. Everything seems to need you to do something in terminal which I understand nothing about and aren’t interested in learning.
You may be more interested in the Steam Deck, a ready-to-go Linux gaming system that doesn't require terminal proficiency. Just turn it on and play like a Nintendo Switch.
I don’t feel like buying yet another device when I already have a decent gaming rig. I’ve got a PS4 too but I never use it because I prefer using a mouse and keyboard.
Installing it was a hassle? May I ask how? In my experience it’s windows that’s a hassle to install. The non-descript error messages, it randomly rebooting like 6 times during installation was pretty jarring, it takes ages even for an NVME drive.
On Linux it’s generally next next username password next next and we’re done. Maybe on a laptop you’ll need to install WiFi drivers manually if it’s a crappy Broadcom WiFi adapter, but that’s not been an issue for years I don’t think.
And as for needing to do stuff in terminal I don’t really see that either. Everything seems to be accessible in the GUI, I can’t really think of any normal task that requires the terminal
Every time I tried installing, it failed in some new way. It wasn’t consistent so I had no idea how to troubleshoot it. It wasn’t asking which hard drive to install it onto, the installer was being extremely slow and unresponsive, the non-safe graphics option wasn’t working at all… I basically just had to abort the installation and start again like 10 times. What finally made it work was putting a different version of Ubuntu on the boot USB and using a different USB port and stick along with the safe graphics istallation. Even now it’s still giving me some TOCBLOCK error on boot, but everything seems to work fine anyways.
This was the quide for installing drivers for my wifi adapter for example. Maybe there is easier way but each one I found needed you to use terminal. Even the manual that came with the wifi stick.
Death, taxes and this post on Lemmy
i just saw this for the first time and it brought me joy
1 day cannot pass without this article getting reposted across various communities.
Yeah, these are getting really annoying.
As someone on Linux, and who thinks performance is generally slightly better on my machine after switching, I totally agree. This post has been old for a while now. Get some more data and then post that new thing or stop posting it.
I swear people just scroll through lemmy, see a post they like and then think to themselves, “this is cool, I should post this on lemmy!”
It’s okay. Lemmy isn’t a wiki. Content is organized temporally. Imagine these conversations as bar conversations (just because one group had a conversation one night, doesn’t mean another group can’t repeat it the next). If you are annoyed that the algo keeps giving you the same stuff, sort by All and New Comments and you’ll find niche communities to subscribe to.
A Lemmy option to hide posts of links already red in another post would be neat. (First time I see this one though)
Testing done on specific hardware and not a broad spectrum of machines is as relevant as asking one person their political opinion and saying that applies to their whole nation.
Well sure but rephrased it’s just “Three Linux distros that embarrass Windows 11 in gaming performance.” which to me, is equally interesting.
“on that one specific machine.”
You’re missing that part from your premise and it’s the important one.
Notice how they didn’t use one with an Nvidia GPU… Or even hardware released this year either…
Edit: Aaaw, I made you angwy and you downvoted me :(
The Nvidia drivers perform fine generally but it would be nice to verify it.
It’s funny because you say that and at the same time it’s the first question asked when someone has a hard time gaming on their Linux setup, “Nvidia GPU?”, even in this thread it’s come up.
lemmy.world/comment/5993627
The issue isn’t performance, it’s Nvidia’s unstable drivers.
E: fuck me, are people stupid? Performance and stability are not the same thing.
Performance on Nvidia cards on Linux is fine. The issue is the bizarre issues you have like multi-monitor weirdness or adaptive refresh rate not working properly. Nvidia’s drivers need kinks worked out but they aren’t slower.
You realise that not having access to stable drivers is a performance issue because it means games don’t run properly or at all?
“The issue isn’t my bike, it’s the bent wheels on it!”
.
Wow you’re *incredibly* smart.I certainly am smarter than the people who base their conclusion of an OS performance being better than another OS’ on a test made on a single hardware setup.
It’s also very funny that when people say they have a hard time making games run on Linux and they mention that they have an Nvidia GPU the first reaction is “Oh yeah, that’s why” and then they’re told to try whatever voodoo magic is in season at the moment to make it run properly but you’re here saying “Oh no, there’s no problem in game!” Yeah, because the problem is actually loading the game inthe first place so there can’t be any issues IN it if you can’t get in!
.
I don’t know why you’re not upset that they present it as a fact when they only tested on one machine with AMD hardware to come to a general conclusion as if it applied to all hardware.
You don’t need to defend some random OS.
.
I don’t see the issue with testing it using fixed hardware, they made that clear in the article.
I’m not defending some random OS, the facts presented speak for themselves. Stop projecting.
Top comment in that chain explain exactly what the issue is.
Irrelevant to someone that wants their game to run.
I didn’t say otherwise. We were talking performance, not stability, that’s why I said the word performance, then said Nvidia’s drivers were unstable.
Understand? Performance means performance and stability means stability. I can appreciate that might be hard to grasp, but they’re different words for a reason, and that reason is they mean different things.
I don’t know why I bother talking to morons on Lemmy who deliberately misinterpret what people say and use that as a gotcha. You’re not smart for using a straw man argument.
Nvidia needs to sort their shit out.
.
Nvidia isnt so bad if you’re on a stable distro it supports and using x(though Ive heard wayland support is improving for it). On rolling or more cutting edge distros where the kernel is likely to change every few weeks and major DE versions might ship that proprietary driver will hurt.
That said while amd is generally better on linux for this reason it’s worth mentioning that it has two huge flaws:
1.Its not perfect like the fans mention. As someone who owned a 3500u and 6650u apu life under amd isnt always sunny. 3500u had a kernel regression for about half a year that prevented the cpu from idling and rembrant apus have an issue where the whole system locks up which seems to come and go(feels like it’s gone for now but Ive thought that before). Desktop gpus are better, but they still did suffer from driver bugs. I think my experience with my 5600xt was better than windows fans had for that generation, but it was not entirely stable and I did suffer from many kernel panics and system freezes. A few mesa and kernel releases fixed that, but it wasnt perfectly smooth. In addition to that no hdmi 2.1 support which is fine unless you game using your nice oled tv because no tvs come with display port. Proprietary drivers do allow for supporting some of the more obnoxious features that arent allowed.
So while there is a lot of pro amd comments in the linux world and its worth acknowledging that the open source drivers are generally good it’s not perfect and the grass isnt always greener.
Just from that comment we can see how far from mainstream adoption Linux is for gaming… You really need to want to understand how things work to fix things that might not work natively. Not every gamer wants to be super knowledgeable about computers, most just want to play games. Heck, I’m very good with computers and I know that what little time I have to play games I don’t want to spend trying to make them work…
article title: windows DEAD LAST!
also in the same article: “… When it comes to FPS, the overall leader in testing was Nobara Linux, with Arch Linux and Pop!_OS trailing by 1–5%. Windows 11, however, was only 6% behind Nobara Linux. So, **there isn’t a massive performance delta here, **”
.
gaming and the abundance of software and third party support and tutorials on windows is why I haven’t taken the dive to linux yet. So yeah, if linux does gaming as well or better my migration is more and more likely.
.
I’m gonna be that Linux bro and tell you to switch 😁 I made the full switch earlier this year and I’ve been amazed by how good proton is. There’s only been one game I couldn’t get to run until I did by installing some Microsoft VC runtime. Give it a shot! You just might be pleasantly surprised as I was.
is the point of article not to stroke the ego of the Linux absolutists that have some weird chip on their shoulders when it comes to video games?
.
No it hasn’t, some games run better on the hardware tested when running Linux, some games don’t work at all on Linux whereas all games run on Windows.
Come back when they test multiple machines running various hardware and when they compare the experience setting up said machines to actually run the games.
You’re exactly the person this article was written for, someone who wants their opinion reinforced because they won’t take the time to analyze the data presented.
.
the linux wars!! lets see who wins. also, its a friendly war, microsoft loves and will support linux
It’s probably more cost effective to run Azure Services on Linux machines than Windows machines.
Microsoft has a how to for Installing Linux on the desktop.
Embrace. Extend. Extinguish.
Pick the bones clean.
CC: @OldQWERTYbastard@lemmy.world
They… accepted that they’re not killing Linux, yet. Back in the 2000s, before Azure, they felt quite threated by Linux and ‘Microsoft Linux’ was a joke. The then-CEO Steve Ballmer called Linux a ‘cancer’.
I’ve been out of the industry for a while, but unless Windows was completely rewritten from the ground up in the last 5 years, this doesn’t surprise me. That OS has always been a hot, bloated mess. And no, I’m not a Linux bro. I use another heavily commercialised OS that doesn’t run Windows because I no longer have the energy to care.
An OS written on Unix can outperform Windows? I’m shocked.
News flash, Windows is garbage.
Jawohl, jawohl.
CC: @OldQWERTYbastard@lemmy.world
<img alt="" src="https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/05590122-d1a2-473f-91d3-909f0149d8fb.png">
windows is overbloated garbage
Maybe. But it does so in ALL OF THE GAMES!!!
Unless you’re super into Fortnite or CoD, Linux plays virtually all of them too.
Linux has all the games I care about. So no need for windowd
I can’t get Spiderman 2 or Ghost of Tsushima to run on Windows. What am I doing wrong?
Did NixOS join the party against Windows in performance tests?
windows 11 able to play games that linux distros cant*
Only because the publisher or developer specifically don’t want their games played on Linux. And it’s mostly because of anticheat
Yeah, same story like beeper and apple
I’m not deep on how the core of an OS works, but to my understanding, the kernel of linux should be more robust and reliable, shouldn’t it always be performing better than windows on the same hardware?
Where could I read information on the things that hinder performance on linux, does anybody have any educational resources?
On Linux, you run windows programs through wine, which is an additional layer that can theoretically slow down the program.
Also, windows supports certain constructs like io completion ports or WaitForMultipleObjects that historically haven’t been emulated efficiently on Linux since it lacked comparable primitives, although those specific ones have been greatly improved in recent years with io_uring and FUTEX_WAIT_MULTIPLE.
There have been similar issues with direct3D since wine used to have to emulate it in OpenGL, but with vkd3d, wine has more opportunities to efficiently implement the d3d apis.
Basically wine being slower was the norm until quite recently.
Thanks to the one crazy guy valve contracts making proton… It’s crazy how his work basically made gaming on Linux a thing. But yeah the other major thing, which you mentioned, is games/game engines using directX9, directX10 and directX11 (the windows 3d graphics libraries) have their API/rendering calls mapped directly to Vulkan. Those APIs were easier to use but from my understanding (I’m no graphics expert) didn’t have the ability to use the full potential of the hardware, and basically had a single channel/thread to the GPU. DirectX12 and Vulkan are much more difficult to use, and some games have used them horribly such that DX11 performs better than DX12, but a good implementation can take advantage of multichannel/multithreaded communication to the GPU allowing much faster and efficient data transfer. They allow the engine programmer to have much more control of the hardware. So vkd3d/proton gives that massive performance impact by mapping the graphics calls from an older API to a newer one. I have not looked into how it’s implemented but it’s basically magic. This was the main reason why wine kinda sucked for gaming before proton.
The Windows scheduler is actually pretty decent, it’s been a few years since I looked into it but I think Windows soft-real time scheduling was better than the one Linux used, though idk if games even use that.
The thing holding Linux back, mostly just for online games with anticheat, is anticheat developers reluctance to port to Linux. I believe do to the differences between users pace and kernel space on Windows VS Linux makes bypassing the anticheat on Linux much easier, or the anticheat can use the same tricks that it does on windows.
I’ve heard that Linux’s task scheduler is just much better than windows’, so it kinda makes sense that all would beat Windows.
A scientific judgement for sure.
I keep hearing and seeing from seemingly everyone that Linux gaming is better basically every month, how it keeps improving and stuff (like the article here)
But for me personally it never did in the last 5 years, whenever I try to step out if emulation and back to windows exlusove games? Its like 5 bullet Russian roulette, if it works at all and doesn’t stop working for inexlicitly no reason
What are yall doing to actually make things work somewhat reasonable (default lutris, proton, or ge has never even renowtly worked how well for me, at all)
For me default proton “just works” usually. But I play a lot of indie games
Modern Linux kernel and steam with proton, and in a few instances lutris with wine. Unless it has anticheet, it’ll play pretty well.
what black magic are you using to make them work
AMD 7600x and 6700xt, Debian 12… proton, wine, keyboard and mouse? Been using it no problem with cyberpunk and Starfield for a few months now. Play Diablo 4 and overwatch with my kids. Been gaming on Linux for almost 4 years now. It HAS come a very very long way since the steamdeck was launched though. Proton and lutris are the glue that hold it all together.
idk what kinda glue you are thinking about, but it aint the one im seeing gtx 1660 super here and distro agnostic for me, same problems all around
cyberpunk, a slideshow at best, tried several times and several configs diablo 4 (got it from a friend), never launched, cause battlnet never works
I’m convinced it’s my AMD graphics that are making things so easy for me. I have had no issues at all with their drivers. Ran arch with no issues for a few years, now Debian for a few months. Have never had an nvidia card.
I have been using an all AMD system for years on Linux and haven’t had any issues. Some coworkers with Nvidia graphics said it was a nightmare. So it must be the AMD drivers
I have over 200 hours in cyberpunk on Linux. The gog version is a little bit more work to setup the steam version. If you have it on steam, and have steam installed natively (not inside wine) it should work assuming you have the correct GPU drivers installed.
I’ve always had weird, buggy shit with Nvidias Linux drivers. AMD is pretty great though.
You could try an open source game like xonotic that supports Linux to test as well.
The only issues left with Windows-Only games is their crippeling-for-purpose anti-cheat code. Anything else works better on Linux.
So the question is whether to support those BDSM anti-cheat games, or get a better gaming experience.
It actually works flawlessly, except for those windows only games of those ones with anticheat bullshit. Especial on AMD, as all the drivers are baked into the kernel and it’s literally plug and play.